Possible cancer again - need advice
I have been here before when I had tongue cancer and now I have a lump near my right tonsil that I am very concerned about considering I have had oral cancer before.
I see an ENT to monitor my tongue cancer situation and he is a highly skilled and experienced surgeon whose practice focuses on head and neck cancer. He is not the one who did my tongue surgery because that didn't go so well but I have been seeing him for a few years. I really want him to do the biopsy and subsequent surgery if that is needed but I am not comfortable with getting the rest of the treatment done (radiation if needed) at the hospital he is affiliated with. I prefer to have any radiation done at another area hospital that has a proton therapy center in case I could qualify for that. This ENT used to be affiliated with that hospital but moved to where he is now a few years ago. Also, the hospital with the proton therapy center is not a comprehensive cancer center but they deal with a lot of cancer and have a head and neck cancer clinic. Neither of our area hospitals that are comprehensive cancer centers have a proton therapy center.
How important is it that I stay with the same hospital for the entire treatment if I have my present ENT do my surgery and this turns out to be cancer? I'm sure it isn't ideal but is it okay to have surgery with a doctor at one hospital and get the rest of the treatment at another hospital? Also, how important is it to be at a comprehensive cancer center especially since they don't have a proton therapy center?
One more thing. I tried to make an appointment with a comprehensive cancer center in my state but they don't give you any input on who you get for your doctor and they gave me an ENT who is right out of school and I don't know how skilled he is and that makes me very nervous. Hence, my decision to stick with the ENT I have. Is this normal practice at some of the hospitals?
Thank you for any input you can give me. I am having a lot of trouble making a decision.
Comments
-
katlou,
Well, I'm not a Doctor, but I would think that Tonsil Removal (and sending in a sample for test) is very standard - and likely it wouldn't matter where it was done, as long as he/she was competent.
Certainly, you'd want to wait for those biopsy results, before getting too panicked (although that's easier said than done.)
In the end, it is YOUR treatment, and although it is generally advisable to follow their recommendations - it is up to YOU to decide whose treatment process to choose!
(If you do get your tonsils out, I feel for you ... as mine were removed, at a relatively "older" age - and it was a bit painful for a little while....)
I wish you a "BENIGN" lab test in your near future - and whatever happens ... the BEST possible outcome!
mg
0 -
Thank youmotorcycleguy said:katlou,
Well, I'm not a Doctor, but I would think that Tonsil Removal (and sending in a sample for test) is very standard - and likely it wouldn't matter where it was done, as long as he/she was competent.
Certainly, you'd want to wait for those biopsy results, before getting too panicked (although that's easier said than done.)
In the end, it is YOUR treatment, and although it is generally advisable to follow their recommendations - it is up to YOU to decide whose treatment process to choose!
(If you do get your tonsils out, I feel for you ... as mine were removed, at a relatively "older" age - and it was a bit painful for a little while....)
I wish you a "BENIGN" lab test in your near future - and whatever happens ... the BEST possible outcome!
mg
Thank you, MG, for your well wishes and warning about the painful tonsil removal. I am waiting for my husband to get his Covid vaccination, which is tomorrow, before I proceed. So I am also of an older adult age and I have heard that tonsil removal is not pleasant for older adults. My lump is below the tonsil so if the biopsy is benign I hopefully won't need the tonsil removed. I hope you weren't in pain for too long after your tonsil removal.
After posting here it occurred to me that once the surgery is over and if it is cancer that after they come up with a treatment plan for me that I should get a second opinion. So I will get my second opinion at the hospital with the proton therapy center to see if I qualify for that if radiation is recommended. That will get me into the other hospital system.
Thanks again.
0 -
Motorcycleguymotorcycleguy said:katlou,
My Cancer was Nasopharyngeal (nasal passage) - and they still removed my tonsils. To be honest, I can't imagine that they wouldn't go ahead and remove them completely - as theoretically they are not necessary - and it removes one potential targer for Cancer to relocate to, in the future.
But, as I mention, I'm not a Doctor - just a know-it-all, electrical engineer .. LOL!
Tonsil removal was painful - but as I recall only lasted maybe a week. If you do have them removed, you'll be over it, before you know it!
I got radiation, myself - but in the event you DO need further treatment, I'd be interested to hear about proton therapy.
(Hopefully, you'll get the "benign" report ... and forget all about all of this.)
I'm glad your husband is getting his Covid vaccination. I'm out west, U.S. - so they are 2-part doses out here. Hopefully, he only needs the single dose.
Hang in there ... no matter what happens, you'll get through this!
mg
I will definitely be posting about proton therapy if it turns out I have cancer and I qualify for proton therapy. I have read that it is less damaging to the surrounding tissue and you have less side effects but it is only recommended for certain cases where they can use more targeted radiation, at least at the proton therapy center that I plan to look into.
We have to get the 2-part Covid vaccine doses here too but my husband and I figure that he will at least have some protection a few weeks after the first dose. I'm not sure it would be wise to wait until two weeks after his second dose to get myself checked out.
Thanks again for your well wishes.
0 -
Just opinion but I would
Just opinion but I would actually be more happy with a doc recently out of school. The tech and treatment on cancer has come such a long way in the last 10-20 yrs and you know a new guy isnt going to be stuck in the old ways.
0 -
katlou,
My Cancer was Nasopharyngeal (nasal passage) - and they still removed my tonsils. To be honest, I can't imagine that they wouldn't go ahead and remove them completely - as theoretically they are not necessary - and it removes one potential targer for Cancer to relocate to, in the future.
But, as I mention, I'm not a Doctor - just a know-it-all, electrical engineer .. LOL!
Tonsil removal was painful - but as I recall only lasted maybe a week. If you do have them removed, you'll be over it, before you know it!
I got radiation, myself - but in the event you DO need further treatment, I'd be interested to hear about proton therapy.
(Hopefully, you'll get the "benign" report ... and forget all about all of this.)
I'm glad your husband is getting his Covid vaccination. I'm out west, U.S. - so they are 2-part doses out here. Hopefully, he only needs the single dose.
Hang in there ... no matter what happens, you'll get through this!
mg
0 -
Thank you for your inputThe Cincinnati Kid said:Just opinion but I would
Just opinion but I would actually be more happy with a doc recently out of school. The tech and treatment on cancer has come such a long way in the last 10-20 yrs and you know a new guy isnt going to be stuck in the old ways.
Thank you for your input. I have thought about what you are saying about a new doctor being up on the latest and I agree with you on that but I am concerned about the surgical experience. My ENT has years of surgical experience and uses the latest technology (TORS). You have given me something to think about and I will definitely keep what you said in mind.
0 -
I had Proton Therapy
3 yrs ago for right side tonsil and one lymph node. My ENT that did the fine needle biopsy and tonsil biopsy was from the Universtiy of Wisconsin cancer center but I had my 6 week proton beam radiation therapy at Mayo clinic 3 hours drive away because UW didnt offer proton therapy. My ENT did not remove the tonsil because the proton beam rads took care of it. (zapped) I faired quite well thru treatment and post. recovered all taste about 5 weeks post therapy. saliva still good. My cancer was caught early. I do have occasional stiffness and slight muscle spasms on my right side of neck. but minimal. Hope this helps. Good luck!
0 -
katlou First Thing
Is that it's not cancer till they say it's cancer. Also since my last escapade with cancer, I have been seeing my ENT from Hershey Medical every three months. The last time I was there he scoped me and did the regular checkup and when he was done said everything looks good "Except" there is a wort near or just above your left tonsil and should not be a problem but he wanted to biopsy it just to be safe. So he did and Praise God it turned out to be negative. But I had never heard of having a wort inside your mouth or internally at all just the ones we always see on the outside like on our fingers, etc. So it just goes to show what I know and it shows why you go to a specialist in these things. Also since my last escapade with cancer, they wanted me to do follow-up rads and they recommended proton therapy. I was operated on in Hershey, PA and I was going to have to go to Philadelphia PA for the proton so I would think it would be the same for you as you can keep your ENT and get the proton at another facility. I did not feel up to 30 trips to Philadelphia and back so I opted for my local cancer center with an excellent radiation doctor who treated me during my first cancer and he and his team came up with a plan using the cyberknife. Wishing You The Best-Take care-God Bless-Russ
0 -
Thank you for sharingskidog said:I had Proton Therapy
3 yrs ago for right side tonsil and one lymph node. My ENT that did the fine needle biopsy and tonsil biopsy was from the Universtiy of Wisconsin cancer center but I had my 6 week proton beam radiation therapy at Mayo clinic 3 hours drive away because UW didnt offer proton therapy. My ENT did not remove the tonsil because the proton beam rads took care of it. (zapped) I faired quite well thru treatment and post. recovered all taste about 5 weeks post therapy. saliva still good. My cancer was caught early. I do have occasional stiffness and slight muscle spasms on my right side of neck. but minimal. Hope this helps. Good luck!
Thank you for sharing your experience. The more information I get the better I feel. Of course I need to wait and see what the biopsy results say and if it is cancer is it an early enough stage for proton therapy. I am glad that things went so well for you.
0 -
I knew you were going to say that...wbcgaruss said:katlou First Thing
Is that it's not cancer till they say it's cancer. Also since my last escapade with cancer, I have been seeing my ENT from Hershey Medical every three months. The last time I was there he scoped me and did the regular checkup and when he was done said everything looks good "Except" there is a wort near or just above your left tonsil and should not be a problem but he wanted to biopsy it just to be safe. So he did and Praise God it turned out to be negative. But I had never heard of having a wort inside your mouth or internally at all just the ones we always see on the outside like on our fingers, etc. So it just goes to show what I know and it shows why you go to a specialist in these things. Also since my last escapade with cancer, they wanted me to do follow-up rads and they recommended proton therapy. I was operated on in Hershey, PA and I was going to have to go to Philadelphia PA for the proton so I would think it would be the same for you as you can keep your ENT and get the proton at another facility. I did not feel up to 30 trips to Philadelphia and back so I opted for my local cancer center with an excellent radiation doctor who treated me during my first cancer and he and his team came up with a plan using the cyberknife. Wishing You The Best-Take care-God Bless-Russ
it's not cancer til they say it's cancer. I wouldn't be so concerned if I didn't have a previous cancer. This lump isn't on the surface like a wart would be. It is inside some tissue that is below my tonsil. You can't even see it, but I can feel it with my finger and I have the sensation that there is something there when I swallow. I probably wouldn't have even noticed it if I wasn't so diligent about keeping an eye on my mouth but it is a new lump.
Thank you for your input on this. I know you have been through a lot and I am glad that you seem to be doing well. Driving a long distance every day for 6 weeks for radiation would really be tiring so I am glad that you were able to get your treatment locally. They do use Cyberknife at the hospital that my ENT works out of so maybe that could be looked at as an option as well if it turns out I have cancer and I would qualify for this. Thank you for mentioning that. I am trying to look at all my options so I don't get overwhelmed trying to make a decision later on. Thanks for your well wishes.
0 -
katlou I Did Not Meankatlou said:I knew you were going to say that...
it's not cancer til they say it's cancer. I wouldn't be so concerned if I didn't have a previous cancer. This lump isn't on the surface like a wart would be. It is inside some tissue that is below my tonsil. You can't even see it, but I can feel it with my finger and I have the sensation that there is something there when I swallow. I probably wouldn't have even noticed it if I wasn't so diligent about keeping an eye on my mouth but it is a new lump.
Thank you for your input on this. I know you have been through a lot and I am glad that you seem to be doing well. Driving a long distance every day for 6 weeks for radiation would really be tiring so I am glad that you were able to get your treatment locally. They do use Cyberknife at the hospital that my ENT works out of so maybe that could be looked at as an option as well if it turns out I have cancer and I would qualify for this. Thank you for mentioning that. I am trying to look at all my options so I don't get overwhelmed trying to make a decision later on. Thanks for your well wishes.
To trivialize your concern of cancer. Yes, I always say it's not cancer till they say it's cancer and say that even to myself as every new suspect lump or soreness or pain crops up. Trying to console myself and stave off my worries like all of us. Once we have cancer we are always on edge. And some of us had cancer and then got it a second time and then a third and after that, it is not hard to just say to yourself I have cancer again I'm sure it is. The good thing Is you are on top of it and caught it early and are getting it checked out and treated quickly and that is the key to most cancer. Best Regards To you katlou-Take Care-God Bless-Russ
0 -
Also Here On CSNkatlou said:I knew you were going to say that...
it's not cancer til they say it's cancer. I wouldn't be so concerned if I didn't have a previous cancer. This lump isn't on the surface like a wart would be. It is inside some tissue that is below my tonsil. You can't even see it, but I can feel it with my finger and I have the sensation that there is something there when I swallow. I probably wouldn't have even noticed it if I wasn't so diligent about keeping an eye on my mouth but it is a new lump.
Thank you for your input on this. I know you have been through a lot and I am glad that you seem to be doing well. Driving a long distance every day for 6 weeks for radiation would really be tiring so I am glad that you were able to get your treatment locally. They do use Cyberknife at the hospital that my ENT works out of so maybe that could be looked at as an option as well if it turns out I have cancer and I would qualify for this. Thank you for mentioning that. I am trying to look at all my options so I don't get overwhelmed trying to make a decision later on. Thanks for your well wishes.
H & N as the years have gone by I have seen at least several people that had themselves fully convinced and some of us on here too that they had to have cancer as a foregone conclusion as per their family history or the facts they presented of their situation. They were sure they had cancer and then the biopsy results come back or the scans and X-rays, etc and it shows no cancer signs or a negative biopsy. Great news of course but in the meantime, they had themselves a nervous wreck. So this is why we always say on here "it's not cancer till they say it is". Also whether it is or isn't cancer worrying won't help but prayer will-Take Care-God Bless-Russ
0 -
Russ, I'm sorrywbcgaruss said:katlou I Did Not Mean
To trivialize your concern of cancer. Yes, I always say it's not cancer till they say it's cancer and say that even to myself as every new suspect lump or soreness or pain crops up. Trying to console myself and stave off my worries like all of us. Once we have cancer we are always on edge. And some of us had cancer and then got it a second time and then a third and after that, it is not hard to just say to yourself I have cancer again I'm sure it is. The good thing Is you are on top of it and caught it early and are getting it checked out and treated quickly and that is the key to most cancer. Best Regards To you katlou-Take Care-God Bless-Russ
I didn't take it at all that you were trivializing my cancer concern. I read all of your posts and I know that is what you tell everyone and that it is meant to be comforting. I am the type that has to get all the information ahead of time and then if it turns out to be nothing it is a relief but I am now very educated on the subject. I'm not worrying too much about this. I am just trying to prepare myself for the worst and then it can only go up from there. So, no worries, I didn't feel trivialized at all. You are a great comfort and support to a lot of people here.
0 -
If the hospital where your ENT is...
is a comprehensive center (meaning a NCI designated comprehensive or CoC-American College of Surgeons center) then I wouldn't worry too much. Meaning, that if your pathology (biopsy) is reviewed in a multidisciplinary fashion (by ENTs, Medical Oncologists and Radiation Oncologists) then you'll likely get the right diagnosis and from there get the right treatment plan. If that plan includes some type of radiation therapy then you can go to the next step and ask whether proton or IMRT would be right for you. As you already suggest, not all patients qualify for proton due to either disease or insurance coverage reasons. But if you are indicated for radiation and ultimately are approved for proton, I wouldn't worry too much about seeking out that treatment outside of your local hospital.
If you are also prescribed chemotherapy then you might be better off having that done at the proton center as well...I think there are cases where they like to have the radiation done within certain time frames of drug administration.
Ultimately I think once you are recommended for radiation it is really up to you and your pocket book as to whether you go IMRT or proton. Hopefully it's not cancer and you don't need to even worry about it. Best of luck.
Brandon
0 -
OK Then katloukatlou said:Russ, I'm sorry
I didn't take it at all that you were trivializing my cancer concern. I read all of your posts and I know that is what you tell everyone and that it is meant to be comforting. I am the type that has to get all the information ahead of time and then if it turns out to be nothing it is a relief but I am now very educated on the subject. I'm not worrying too much about this. I am just trying to prepare myself for the worst and then it can only go up from there. So, no worries, I didn't feel trivialized at all. You are a great comfort and support to a lot of people here.
Everythings fine and I just did not want to be saying the wrong thing. You are also a great support for folks on here as well in fact we all are supporters on here one way or another-Have a great day-Take Care-God Bless-Russ
0 -
I was hoping you would respondjohnsonbl said:If the hospital where your ENT is...
is a comprehensive center (meaning a NCI designated comprehensive or CoC-American College of Surgeons center) then I wouldn't worry too much. Meaning, that if your pathology (biopsy) is reviewed in a multidisciplinary fashion (by ENTs, Medical Oncologists and Radiation Oncologists) then you'll likely get the right diagnosis and from there get the right treatment plan. If that plan includes some type of radiation therapy then you can go to the next step and ask whether proton or IMRT would be right for you. As you already suggest, not all patients qualify for proton due to either disease or insurance coverage reasons. But if you are indicated for radiation and ultimately are approved for proton, I wouldn't worry too much about seeking out that treatment outside of your local hospital.
If you are also prescribed chemotherapy then you might be better off having that done at the proton center as well...I think there are cases where they like to have the radiation done within certain time frames of drug administration.
Ultimately I think once you are recommended for radiation it is really up to you and your pocket book as to whether you go IMRT or proton. Hopefully it's not cancer and you don't need to even worry about it. Best of luck.
Brandon
You have a lot of valuable information to provide and I am thankful that you took the time to respond to my post. Both hospitals (the one my ENT is out of and the one that does the proton therapy) are listed on the CoC-American College of Surgeons center website. They are both categorized as integrated network cancer programs and they have a multidisciplinary tumor board and a head and neck cancer clinic. Your information was very helpful to me and makes me feel much more comfortable with my decision to have my ENT start the process and if needed end the process at the other hospital hopefully with proton therapy. I have a condition called eosinophilic esophagitis which causes swallowing problems for me in that food gets stuck in my esophagus. I am very concerned that IMRT radiation will be the end of my swallowing capabilities so I am hoping that if this is cancer and I need radiation I can go with proton therapy. Thank you for your input.
0 -
I happen to work...
At the University of Iowa Hospitals and Clinics which has an NCI designated comprehensive cancer center and also happens to have literally one of the best head and neck cancer oncology groups in the country, if not the world. I was already well versed in their capabilities before getting diagnosed and was/am so lucky to have been able to walk down the hall from my office and get care from these folks.
I am a big believer in getting the diagnosis and treatment plan right the first time...which means being somewhere where you have access to a multidisciplinary team that works together. We often see patients come from areas where their physicians (surgeons, oncologists and radiation oncologists) don't work together and the care patients receive is often sub-optimal. Sounds like you have that available to you as well which is excellent.
Given your existing troubles it does make sense to try for proton if you need radiation. I wish you all the best!
Brandon
0 -
Thank youjohnsonbl said:I happen to work...
At the University of Iowa Hospitals and Clinics which has an NCI designated comprehensive cancer center and also happens to have literally one of the best head and neck cancer oncology groups in the country, if not the world. I was already well versed in their capabilities before getting diagnosed and was/am so lucky to have been able to walk down the hall from my office and get care from these folks.
I am a big believer in getting the diagnosis and treatment plan right the first time...which means being somewhere where you have access to a multidisciplinary team that works together. We often see patients come from areas where their physicians (surgeons, oncologists and radiation oncologists) don't work together and the care patients receive is often sub-optimal. Sounds like you have that available to you as well which is excellent.
Given your existing troubles it does make sense to try for proton if you need radiation. I wish you all the best!
Brandon
Thank you, Brandon, for all your helpful information. I was aware that you work at the University of Iowa Hospitals and Clinics as I read all of your posts. I have become quite educated by what you write. You are very lucky to have been able to get your treatment right where you work and at a very reputable hospital.
I have made my appointment with my ENT and I will go from there. Thank you for your well wishes.
0 -
You are in our prayers and thoughts Kat Lou
Kat Lou you are in our prayers and thoughts to be cancer free. Kat Lou you were such a support to me when I went thru my tongue cancer battle and operation and I am so sorry you are going thru this again, but I am hopeful you will hear the very best news of no cancer.
0
Discussion Boards
- All Discussion Boards
- 6 CSN Information
- 6 Welcome to CSN
- 121.9K Cancer specific
- 2.8K Anal Cancer
- 446 Bladder Cancer
- 309 Bone Cancers
- 1.6K Brain Cancer
- 28.5K Breast Cancer
- 398 Childhood Cancers
- 27.9K Colorectal Cancer
- 4.6K Esophageal Cancer
- 1.2K Gynecological Cancers (other than ovarian and uterine)
- 13K Head and Neck Cancer
- 6.4K Kidney Cancer
- 671 Leukemia
- 794 Liver Cancer
- 4.1K Lung Cancer
- 5.1K Lymphoma (Hodgkin and Non-Hodgkin)
- 237 Multiple Myeloma
- 7.1K Ovarian Cancer
- 63 Pancreatic Cancer
- 487 Peritoneal Cancer
- 5.5K Prostate Cancer
- 1.2K Rare and Other Cancers
- 540 Sarcoma
- 734 Skin Cancer
- 653 Stomach Cancer
- 191 Testicular Cancer
- 1.5K Thyroid Cancer
- 5.8K Uterine/Endometrial Cancer
- 6.3K Lifestyle Discussion Boards