Any American Idol Fans? Who are your Faves?

natly15
natly15 Member Posts: 1,941
I think this is the best season EVER and love the judges. J-Lo so far gives constructive criticism, Steven just seems to enjoy all the singing.

I have so many Faves: Scotty (country singer) Pia, Casey, James and Stefano. The talent seems to be far better than most of the stars of today.

Ok I admit it I'm a reality junkie and also love DWTS.
«1

Comments

  • carkris
    carkris Member Posts: 4,553 Member
    I dont remember the names,
    I dont remember the names, but I like the country guy, the rocker, the guy with the "different' voice. I think he went first last night. I also like DWTS
  • disneyfan2008
    disneyfan2008 Member Posts: 6,583 Member
    James James James...
    I want him to win..others are great...but I JUST LIKE him...(he reminds of me of Adam Lambert singing style and love him)
  • dyaneb123
    dyaneb123 Member Posts: 950

    James James James...
    I want him to win..others are great...but I JUST LIKE him...(he reminds of me of Adam Lambert singing style and love him)

    Love James and Casey
    But I also like Paul( the Rod Stewart sounding guy) and I thought Jacob Lusk was awesome last night.
    I along with all my girlfriends have a huge crush on Steven Tyler now. What a cutie.He is so fun to watch!
  • Mitzi333
    Mitzi333 Member Posts: 511 Member

    James James James...
    I want him to win..others are great...but I JUST LIKE him...(he reminds of me of Adam Lambert singing style and love him)

    I agree... Best Season Ever...
    Love the judges. This year's talent is the BEST. My favs... James. Also Like the Rod Steward like singer, Naomka, the Rocker and also the Country guy. Love how the country guy changed the Stevie Wonder song to fit his style. Actually all of the singers ARE extremely good. I'm sure most will be contracts.

    Whose going home tonight??? Drum roll ... ;0)
  • Mitzi333
    Mitzi333 Member Posts: 511 Member

    James James James...
    I want him to win..others are great...but I JUST LIKE him...(he reminds of me of Adam Lambert singing style and love him)

    I agree... Best Season Ever...
    Love the judges. This year's talent is the BEST. My favs... James. Also Like the Rod Steward like singer, Naomka, the Rocker and also the Country guy. Love how the country guy changed the Stevie Wonder song to fit his style. Actually all of the singers ARE extremely good. I'm sure most will be contracts.

    Whose going home tonight??? Drum roll ... ;0)
  • Mitzi333
    Mitzi333 Member Posts: 511 Member

    James James James...
    I want him to win..others are great...but I JUST LIKE him...(he reminds of me of Adam Lambert singing style and love him)

    I agree... Best Season Ever...
    Love the judges. This year's talent is the BEST. My favs... James. Also Like the Rod Steward like singer, Naomka, the Rocker and also the Country guy. Love how the country guy changed the Stevie Wonder song to fit his style. Actually all of the singers ARE extremely good. I'm sure most will be contracts.

    Whose going home tonight??? Drum roll ... ;0)
  • natly15
    natly15 Member Posts: 1,941
    Mitzi333 said:

    I agree... Best Season Ever...
    Love the judges. This year's talent is the BEST. My favs... James. Also Like the Rod Steward like singer, Naomka, the Rocker and also the Country guy. Love how the country guy changed the Stevie Wonder song to fit his style. Actually all of the singers ARE extremely good. I'm sure most will be contracts.

    Whose going home tonight??? Drum roll ... ;0)

    Hmmmm Who's going home tonite3/24 ??
    It could be Stefano based on the judges comments, but I hope not; It could also be that little sweet pea Thia hmmm any ideas? well I guess we'll know by 9 pm eastern daylight time in my neck of the woods.
  • Gabe N Abby Mom
    Gabe N Abby Mom Member Posts: 2,413
    natly15 said:

    Hmmmm Who's going home tonite3/24 ??
    It could be Stefano based on the judges comments, but I hope not; It could also be that little sweet pea Thia hmmm any ideas? well I guess we'll know by 9 pm eastern daylight time in my neck of the woods.

    I think the bottom 3 will be
    I think the bottom 3 will be Stefano, Thia, and the girl who was in the bottom last week. But I can't predict who will go home. I've thought for a couple of weeks that Naima should have gone home...but I think she'll be safe again.

    Like you, I'll be watching tonight to see.

    Hugs,

    Linda
  • BlownAway60
    BlownAway60 Member Posts: 851
    I like Scotty and James. I
    I like Scotty and James. I also like Thia.

    Hugs

    Donna
  • Double Whammy
    Double Whammy Member Posts: 2,832 Member

    I like Scotty and James. I
    I like Scotty and James. I also like Thia.

    Hugs

    Donna

    I like Pia, Naima, Scotty
    I like Pia, Naima, Scotty and Paul. We'll see who goes home tonight.

    Suzanne

    PS I hate the way young men are wearing their hair these days - maybe I'm just jealous.
  • Survivor73
    Survivor73 Member Posts: 135

    I like Pia, Naima, Scotty
    I like Pia, Naima, Scotty and Paul. We'll see who goes home tonight.

    Suzanne

    PS I hate the way young men are wearing their hair these days - maybe I'm just jealous.

    this year the whole group is great
    So, my fav's are the rocker & Pia...they will be top two...
  • lizzie17
    lizzie17 Member Posts: 548
    Simon
    I have to admit, I really miss Simon!
  • cahjah75
    cahjah75 Member Posts: 2,631
    Natly
    I also watch DWTS! LOL I agree that this years talent is wonderful. As good as Scotty is I'm not a country music lover. I like James, Pia, Naima, Stefano, etc. I just read a TV guide that was a few weeks old and a survey of favs that was taken about the judges was way off in my opinion: Paula Abdul got 73%, Simon got 11%, Tyler & JLo got 7%, Randy and Ellen got 1% each. I would have put Paula at the bottom. I like this year's judges just fine. I'm wondering who will be voted off tonight?????
    Char
  • CypressCynthia
    CypressCynthia Member Posts: 4,014 Member
    OMG, I couldn't believe what
    OMG, I couldn't believe what happened with Casey tonight--he is one of my favorites! I about had a heart attack. What was with that???
  • carkris
    carkris Member Posts: 4,553 Member

    OMG, I couldn't believe what
    OMG, I couldn't believe what happened with Casey tonight--he is one of my favorites! I about had a heart attack. What was with that???

    I was afraid he was having a
    I was afraid he was having a heart attack!!! kind of scary!!!!
  • CypressCynthia
    CypressCynthia Member Posts: 4,014 Member
    carkris said:

    I was afraid he was having a
    I was afraid he was having a heart attack!!! kind of scary!!!!

    Yes, it was very
    Yes, it was very scary--especially after knowing that he has truly been ill.
  • natly15
    natly15 Member Posts: 1,941

    OMG, I couldn't believe what
    OMG, I couldn't believe what happened with Casey tonight--he is one of my favorites! I about had a heart attack. What was with that???

    CC I'm so happy the judges
    CC I'm so happy the judges saved Casey this evening, I want to see more of him. He is a terrific talent and one of my FAVES. Thia, Haley and Naima are some of the weeker singers in my estimation if indeed there are any weak singers this year, and although he is a good looking guy Paul's style is not my cup of tea. They are all so very talented this year it is difficult. I'm so hooked on this season that I may convince my hubby to see them on tour.

    Cahjah those polls are terribly off in my estimation. I don't miss Simon at all. The judging this year is sooo much better. J-Lo has been very good with her comments and Randy sometimes holds on to that old "pitchy" Simon phrase but I think the new judges are bringing Randy around. Simon said nothing of substance to the talent in past seasons. I love the whole upbeat feeling this year has brought. I personally do not like tearing people down too much of that in this world today. Simon was rude and his ego got in the way. I like the way it is this season. Now that's my 2 cents and please feel free to disagree. :)
  • Texasgirl10
    Texasgirl10 Member Posts: 668
    natly15 said:

    CC I'm so happy the judges
    CC I'm so happy the judges saved Casey this evening, I want to see more of him. He is a terrific talent and one of my FAVES. Thia, Haley and Naima are some of the weeker singers in my estimation if indeed there are any weak singers this year, and although he is a good looking guy Paul's style is not my cup of tea. They are all so very talented this year it is difficult. I'm so hooked on this season that I may convince my hubby to see them on tour.

    Cahjah those polls are terribly off in my estimation. I don't miss Simon at all. The judging this year is sooo much better. J-Lo has been very good with her comments and Randy sometimes holds on to that old "pitchy" Simon phrase but I think the new judges are bringing Randy around. Simon said nothing of substance to the talent in past seasons. I love the whole upbeat feeling this year has brought. I personally do not like tearing people down too much of that in this world today. Simon was rude and his ego got in the way. I like the way it is this season. Now that's my 2 cents and please feel free to disagree. :)

    I like James
    I really like James and so far he is my favorite. But I think they are all very talented this year and it's hard not to like them all. And I must say I LOVE Steven Tyler!!!! I've always been a huge Aerosmith fan and I think Steven Tyler ROCKS!!!
  • disneyfan2008
    disneyfan2008 Member Posts: 6,583 Member
    natly15 said:

    CC I'm so happy the judges
    CC I'm so happy the judges saved Casey this evening, I want to see more of him. He is a terrific talent and one of my FAVES. Thia, Haley and Naima are some of the weeker singers in my estimation if indeed there are any weak singers this year, and although he is a good looking guy Paul's style is not my cup of tea. They are all so very talented this year it is difficult. I'm so hooked on this season that I may convince my hubby to see them on tour.

    Cahjah those polls are terribly off in my estimation. I don't miss Simon at all. The judging this year is sooo much better. J-Lo has been very good with her comments and Randy sometimes holds on to that old "pitchy" Simon phrase but I think the new judges are bringing Randy around. Simon said nothing of substance to the talent in past seasons. I love the whole upbeat feeling this year has brought. I personally do not like tearing people down too much of that in this world today. Simon was rude and his ego got in the way. I like the way it is this season. Now that's my 2 cents and please feel free to disagree. :)

    wow his face when the stopped him from singing..
    one I am sure cuz out of time and two knew they were saving him and sending all on tour...
  • disneyfan2008
    disneyfan2008 Member Posts: 6,583 Member

    I like James
    I really like James and so far he is my favorite. But I think they are all very talented this year and it's hard not to like them all. And I must say I LOVE Steven Tyler!!!! I've always been a huge Aerosmith fan and I think Steven Tyler ROCKS!!!

    James...#1 for me...
    I agree with you...