Pete- or Tans or anyone's feedback

Options
janie1
janie1 Member Posts: 753 Member
edited March 2012 in Colorectal Cancer #1
Pete. You mentioned zinc on another thread.
Would taking cimetadine (sp?) Still be useful if it changes stomach acid, which would change zinc levels, which would hinder absorption of nutrients. Sorry, long question. Was wondering your thoughts on this. Maybe if the right dosages are used it would be ok.
Do you still take cimetadine, or are you temporarily off of it due to tests that you are having?
Thanks as always.

Comments

  • pete43lost_at_sea
    pete43lost_at_sea Member Posts: 3,900 Member
    Options
    you had to ask this, GREAT question janie
    thanks for asking, i will share my cimetidine story so far, it may change tomorrow.

    i have been off on off on off

    i am off it now because i have had recurring dysbiosis.

    yes it reduces stomach acid, and you can boost tanstafl has explained mentioned many bits and pieces about cimetidine and i will let him comment.

    just google ppi and warning, my functional gp told me about this and was not convinced
    by all the studies i had proving how good cimetidine was, even the lef advisory about colorectal protocols, documented here recently has it in. when i quizzed the lef onc about it, he said it was a disputed point. i emailed lef about this and never got a response.

    LEF EMAIL AND BLOG
    i hope you are well and lef is making progress.

    i have been on the most amazing toxicology conference in the states and am sorting out my toxicants heavy metals and pcbs eta.

    http://petertrayhurn.blogspot.com.au/2012/03/going-to-see-philip-day-friday-18th.html#!http://petertrayhurn.blogspot.com/2012/03/lef-needs-to-review-cimetidine-for.html

    I would sincerely appreciate an answer, as i suspect todds advice is correct from the conference.

    the entire conference mp3 is on my blog, take a copy and the cimetidine advice is in the second last recording. its a great listen for most cancer patients.

    by the way, most colorectals have had folfox, see my blog for the discussion on platinum poisoning after folfox.

    you could put this up as a good story as what your onc does not tell you, and what you can find when you start taking responsibility for your own health.

    thanks again to all the guys andgals at lef, my health at the moment is improvioing, largely due to your support and advice.


    So here is the PPI warning
    http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/233272.php

    I could not confirm my lewis status.
    I had some significant decrease in my sex life. Given that i have given up drugs, grog and all the food i used to eat for this healthy cancer battle. i was dammed if i would given up sex. for some guys cimetidine is pretty devastating in that area. I think the sex issue is only a guy problem. even my onc was giggling about my sex problems in the last consult with my wife when we talked about me going off cimetidine. she said its common knowledge.

    see the recent posts somewhere here about probiotics and an acid environment screwing the good bugs, their goes your immune system and a background load of toxins on your liver. so getting the acid balance correct is something i want to leave to mother nature and god. but i will be interested in tanstafl comments.

    so i have digestive enzymes , a few types and will get back onto them,
    i also have some hcl pepsin. when i was trying to play god.
    i have off these as i have been doing advanced stool tests to get to the bottom of the recurring dysbiosis and they want your gut the way it is naturally without supplements.

    in theory these all help, but as you said acid is key to nutrient absorption. if you just eat western crap food, then it makes little difference.

    if you care about your body, you want to give it essential minerals, vitamins etc etc etc.
    if you eat well, organic, vegan, juice, some supplements well its a waste of money if you poo them down the loo and the goodness does not get into the plasma, and then to the cells that needs the goodies.

    so i am off cimetidine temporarily. expecting it to be a long break.

    so read read read, get lots of advice most of it conflicting.

    welcome to colorectal survivorship in the twenty first century.

    hugs,
    pete

    ps so i have drop aspirin and cimetidine, but today i have picked up iodine and b12
    its not a good day if i don't pop a few hundred pills. we got to keep the supplement makers in business or else a big part of the us economy would grind to a halt. only joking!

    pps this link is real good at explaining phase detox
    http://www.health-diets.net/database/detoxification/

    ppps goto my blog and search cimetidine, i was really surprised how much it came up.
    the lef link is below
    http://www.blogger.com/blogger.g?blogID=2969302819198622741#editor/target=post;postID=7717452709949402681
  • smokeyjoe
    smokeyjoe Member Posts: 1,425 Member
    Options

    you had to ask this, GREAT question janie
    thanks for asking, i will share my cimetidine story so far, it may change tomorrow.

    i have been off on off on off

    i am off it now because i have had recurring dysbiosis.

    yes it reduces stomach acid, and you can boost tanstafl has explained mentioned many bits and pieces about cimetidine and i will let him comment.

    just google ppi and warning, my functional gp told me about this and was not convinced
    by all the studies i had proving how good cimetidine was, even the lef advisory about colorectal protocols, documented here recently has it in. when i quizzed the lef onc about it, he said it was a disputed point. i emailed lef about this and never got a response.

    LEF EMAIL AND BLOG
    i hope you are well and lef is making progress.

    i have been on the most amazing toxicology conference in the states and am sorting out my toxicants heavy metals and pcbs eta.

    http://petertrayhurn.blogspot.com.au/2012/03/going-to-see-philip-day-friday-18th.html#!http://petertrayhurn.blogspot.com/2012/03/lef-needs-to-review-cimetidine-for.html

    I would sincerely appreciate an answer, as i suspect todds advice is correct from the conference.

    the entire conference mp3 is on my blog, take a copy and the cimetidine advice is in the second last recording. its a great listen for most cancer patients.

    by the way, most colorectals have had folfox, see my blog for the discussion on platinum poisoning after folfox.

    you could put this up as a good story as what your onc does not tell you, and what you can find when you start taking responsibility for your own health.

    thanks again to all the guys andgals at lef, my health at the moment is improvioing, largely due to your support and advice.


    So here is the PPI warning
    http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/233272.php

    I could not confirm my lewis status.
    I had some significant decrease in my sex life. Given that i have given up drugs, grog and all the food i used to eat for this healthy cancer battle. i was dammed if i would given up sex. for some guys cimetidine is pretty devastating in that area. I think the sex issue is only a guy problem. even my onc was giggling about my sex problems in the last consult with my wife when we talked about me going off cimetidine. she said its common knowledge.

    see the recent posts somewhere here about probiotics and an acid environment screwing the good bugs, their goes your immune system and a background load of toxins on your liver. so getting the acid balance correct is something i want to leave to mother nature and god. but i will be interested in tanstafl comments.

    so i have digestive enzymes , a few types and will get back onto them,
    i also have some hcl pepsin. when i was trying to play god.
    i have off these as i have been doing advanced stool tests to get to the bottom of the recurring dysbiosis and they want your gut the way it is naturally without supplements.

    in theory these all help, but as you said acid is key to nutrient absorption. if you just eat western crap food, then it makes little difference.

    if you care about your body, you want to give it essential minerals, vitamins etc etc etc.
    if you eat well, organic, vegan, juice, some supplements well its a waste of money if you poo them down the loo and the goodness does not get into the plasma, and then to the cells that needs the goodies.

    so i am off cimetidine temporarily. expecting it to be a long break.

    so read read read, get lots of advice most of it conflicting.

    welcome to colorectal survivorship in the twenty first century.

    hugs,
    pete

    ps so i have drop aspirin and cimetidine, but today i have picked up iodine and b12
    its not a good day if i don't pop a few hundred pills. we got to keep the supplement makers in business or else a big part of the us economy would grind to a halt. only joking!

    pps this link is real good at explaining phase detox
    http://www.health-diets.net/database/detoxification/

    ppps goto my blog and search cimetidine, i was really surprised how much it came up.
    the lef link is below
    http://www.blogger.com/blogger.g?blogID=2969302819198622741#editor/target=post;postID=7717452709949402681

    I saw somewhere, not sure
    I saw somewhere, not sure where, but I shall try and find it, but apparently cimetidine affects how your body uses vitamin D.....found it...Effect of cimetidine on hepatic vitamin D metabolism in humans.
    Odes HS, Fraser GM, Krugliak P, Lamprecht SA, Shany S.
    SourceGastroenterology Unit, Soroka Medical Center, Beer-Sheva, Israel.

    Abstract
    Cimetidine inhibits the action of vitamin D-hydroxylase (a hepatic mixed-function oxidase) in the rat. Therefore, the hypothesis was tested that this H2 receptor antagonist would affect vitamin D metabolism in humans. Nine adult patients were treated with 400 mg cimetidine orally twice daily during a period from winter to summer, when days were becoming longer. Serum levels of 25-hydroxyvitamin D, 24,25-dihydroxyvitamin D and 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D were monitored before treatment, after 4 weeks of treatment, and 1 month after cessation of treatment. No seasonal increase in the level of 25-hydroxyvitamin D was observed during the period of treatment, but the level rose significantly after withdrawal of the drug. The other hydroxylates of vitamin D were not affected. Levels of albumin, total calcium, phosphorus and alkaline phosphatase remained normal. The data suggest that short-term treatment with cimetidine could potentially perturb vitamin D metabolism in man.
  • tanstaafl
    tanstaafl Member Posts: 1,313 Member
    Options
    prior discussions
    Previous cimetidine discussions, including some on digestion and vitamin D:
    Cimetidine use
    cimetidine and digestion 101

    My wife was surely vitamin D deficient before diagnosis (like siblings), and has required substantial amounts of vitamin D3 supplements while on chemo and cimetidine to even get minimum acceptable vitamin D blood levels.

    We opted to get a prescription for very high dose vitamin D3, as an alternative treatment addition to the chemotherapy to additionally stress the cancer cells. We check her blood calcium levels monthly.
  • smokeyjoe
    smokeyjoe Member Posts: 1,425 Member
    Options
    tanstaafl said:

    prior discussions
    Previous cimetidine discussions, including some on digestion and vitamin D:
    Cimetidine use
    cimetidine and digestion 101

    My wife was surely vitamin D deficient before diagnosis (like siblings), and has required substantial amounts of vitamin D3 supplements while on chemo and cimetidine to even get minimum acceptable vitamin D blood levels.

    We opted to get a prescription for very high dose vitamin D3, as an alternative treatment addition to the chemotherapy to additionally stress the cancer cells. We check her blood calcium levels monthly.

    Tanstaafl....what do blood
    Tanstaafl....what do blood calcium levels tell you?? I was given my blood requisitions for my next onc. appt. with the request for CEA levels he also wrote calcium level and I have no clue why he'd make this request. It's been done with my previous bloodwork and is always in the normal range. I compared this one with an ealier one I had and th calcium level this time was lower than last.....what does blood calcium levels indicate???
  • tanstaafl
    tanstaafl Member Posts: 1,313 Member
    Options
    smokeyjoe said:

    Tanstaafl....what do blood
    Tanstaafl....what do blood calcium levels tell you?? I was given my blood requisitions for my next onc. appt. with the request for CEA levels he also wrote calcium level and I have no clue why he'd make this request. It's been done with my previous bloodwork and is always in the normal range. I compared this one with an ealier one I had and th calcium level this time was lower than last.....what does blood calcium levels indicate???

    blood calcium
    Blood calcium is considered a cheaper, more direct measure of potential vitamin D and calcium supplement problems. The background concern is that high levels of vitamin D and a high supplement intake of calcium might lead to hypercalcemia. Calcium blood levels somewhat above the normal range for calcium cause concern, and then at too high levels, form solid calcium salts in the kidney - "calcium toxicity".

    The solubility is figured simplistically as a product of [calcium] x [phosporus], and this product is what the "pros" use in tracking hypercalcemia on close calls. From a bone formation point of view magnesium and vitamin K2 are important ingredients and both help balance calcium and vitamin D3 levels in the body.

    Chemo makes it hard to keep vitamin D3 and calcium adequate for my wife by normal diet alone. Supplemental vitamin D3 and calcium tradeoffs need to be done by knowledgeable persons and monitored. We use a lot of vitamin D3, balanced with magnesium and vitamin K2, and avoid calcium supplements - my wife sometimes gets a fair amount of calcium in other supplements. Erratic use of the supplements with calcium stabilizers (e.g. pancreatin and betaine HCl) causes swings in her calcium blood levels above/below the mid point, but always within range.
  • smokeyjoe
    smokeyjoe Member Posts: 1,425 Member
    Options
    tanstaafl said:

    blood calcium
    Blood calcium is considered a cheaper, more direct measure of potential vitamin D and calcium supplement problems. The background concern is that high levels of vitamin D and a high supplement intake of calcium might lead to hypercalcemia. Calcium blood levels somewhat above the normal range for calcium cause concern, and then at too high levels, form solid calcium salts in the kidney - "calcium toxicity".

    The solubility is figured simplistically as a product of [calcium] x [phosporus], and this product is what the "pros" use in tracking hypercalcemia on close calls. From a bone formation point of view magnesium and vitamin K2 are important ingredients and both help balance calcium and vitamin D3 levels in the body.

    Chemo makes it hard to keep vitamin D3 and calcium adequate for my wife by normal diet alone. Supplemental vitamin D3 and calcium tradeoffs need to be done by knowledgeable persons and monitored. We use a lot of vitamin D3, balanced with magnesium and vitamin K2, and avoid calcium supplements - my wife sometimes gets a fair amount of calcium in other supplements. Erratic use of the supplements with calcium stabilizers (e.g. pancreatin and betaine HCl) causes swings in her calcium blood levels above/below the mid point, but always within range.

    Okay...I was just looking at
    Okay...I was just looking at my bloodwork that I have...I just noticed in July my CEA was .5, I never realized it had gotten that low!! Wow. Now, I'm wondering what it is now, that result wasn't ready when I left my appt. this week. With the calcium last July it was 2.45 it's now at 2.29....so it's basically dropped ...wonder if the cimitidine I'm on recently is causing this drop.... who knows.
  • pete43lost_at_sea
    pete43lost_at_sea Member Posts: 3,900 Member
    Options
    smokeyjoe said:

    I saw somewhere, not sure
    I saw somewhere, not sure where, but I shall try and find it, but apparently cimetidine affects how your body uses vitamin D.....found it...Effect of cimetidine on hepatic vitamin D metabolism in humans.
    Odes HS, Fraser GM, Krugliak P, Lamprecht SA, Shany S.
    SourceGastroenterology Unit, Soroka Medical Center, Beer-Sheva, Israel.

    Abstract
    Cimetidine inhibits the action of vitamin D-hydroxylase (a hepatic mixed-function oxidase) in the rat. Therefore, the hypothesis was tested that this H2 receptor antagonist would affect vitamin D metabolism in humans. Nine adult patients were treated with 400 mg cimetidine orally twice daily during a period from winter to summer, when days were becoming longer. Serum levels of 25-hydroxyvitamin D, 24,25-dihydroxyvitamin D and 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D were monitored before treatment, after 4 weeks of treatment, and 1 month after cessation of treatment. No seasonal increase in the level of 25-hydroxyvitamin D was observed during the period of treatment, but the level rose significantly after withdrawal of the drug. The other hydroxylates of vitamin D were not affected. Levels of albumin, total calcium, phosphorus and alkaline phosphatase remained normal. The data suggest that short-term treatment with cimetidine could potentially perturb vitamin D metabolism in man.

    its interesting that my vit d is going through the roof now
    awesome contribution smokeyjoe, its good that this point is raised in this context.

    i don't want to dissaude anyway from cimetidine, its just not for me at present, as i have not check my ca199 markers done and checked for the lewis type.

    when i have got all my essentil fatty acids, vitamins, minerals at optimum levels as well as full bloods, and somehow checked my tumour is responsive to cimetidine i would consider it. not until then for me.

    getting individual expert advice on this was impossible for me, so i had to piece together my own research based on my own anti cancer strategy.

    for me detox is the key, this implies chelation and i cannot undertake this complex process without a strong detox system.

    i put something up about this months ago, funnily enough now my vit d is at 259 nmol/L just above the toxic level. i have dropped my dose from 10000ui daily to 5000ui.

    its possible going off cimetidine is a factor. this point also is proof of cimetidine's implications for our liver.

    if in doubt leave it out, i never thought i would say that here, but now i am being quiet selective over my supplements if they have unknowable or unquantifiable downsides and also unknowable and unquantifiable upsides.

    hugs,
    pete

    ps my genetic profile says i am a poor vit d converter, this another reason colorectal cancer patients can benefits from a fitgenes or similar genetic profile analysis with recommended epigenetic lifestyle changes. like get more sun, or take more drops. this explains why our response is so individual 1000ui a day is great for some, and 15000ui is inaquate for others. its all mixed up with our genes, the environment and our liver.
  • smokeyjoe
    smokeyjoe Member Posts: 1,425 Member
    Options
    smokeyjoe said:

    Okay...I was just looking at
    Okay...I was just looking at my bloodwork that I have...I just noticed in July my CEA was .5, I never realized it had gotten that low!! Wow. Now, I'm wondering what it is now, that result wasn't ready when I left my appt. this week. With the calcium last July it was 2.45 it's now at 2.29....so it's basically dropped ...wonder if the cimitidine I'm on recently is causing this drop.... who knows.

    You know how body builders
    You know how body builders cycle their supplements....wonder if cycling vitimin D alternating weeks with cimetidine would be of benefit.
  • pete43lost_at_sea
    pete43lost_at_sea Member Posts: 3,900 Member
    Options
    smokeyjoe said:

    You know how body builders
    You know how body builders cycle their supplements....wonder if cycling vitimin D alternating weeks with cimetidine would be of benefit.

    i think cimetidine is more like preventitive and cytotoxic
    its strong point for us cancer was avoiding local immune suppression.
    now i guess if you take it,
    and it suppresses a tumours local immuine suppression than in principle it should
    that tumour to be gobbled by the immune system and indeed you could see decreasing cea's and or a flare as we have discussed here. it depends on where the tumour is in rerlation to the blood supply and the liver.

    hugs,
    pete
  • smokeyjoe
    smokeyjoe Member Posts: 1,425 Member
    Options

    i think cimetidine is more like preventitive and cytotoxic
    its strong point for us cancer was avoiding local immune suppression.
    now i guess if you take it,
    and it suppresses a tumours local immuine suppression than in principle it should
    that tumour to be gobbled by the immune system and indeed you could see decreasing cea's and or a flare as we have discussed here. it depends on where the tumour is in rerlation to the blood supply and the liver.

    hugs,
    pete

    Cimeticline, a selective
    Cimeticline, a selective histamine-2 receptor antagonist, has attracted interest because of its potential as an immune response-modifying drug. Most data suggest that cimetidine has a stimulatory action on the immune system, possibly by blocking of receptors on subsets of T-lymphocytes and inhibiting histamine-induced immune suppression. Several studies have shown that cimeticline can affect the relative number of CD8 + ve lymphocytes and increase the NK cell activity as well as the antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity. Cimeticline has also been used successfully to restore immune functions in patients with malignant disorders, hypogammaglobulinemia and AIDS-related complexes.
    Key words Cimeticline - Immune response - Lymphocytes - Histamine - Interferon

    Supported by the Swedish Cancer Society and the Karolinska Institute
  • tanstaafl
    tanstaafl Member Posts: 1,313 Member
    Options
    smokeyjoe said:

    You know how body builders
    You know how body builders cycle their supplements....wonder if cycling vitimin D alternating weeks with cimetidine would be of benefit.

    steady as she goes
    The fundamentals of cimetidine (for more continuous protection against met cells) suggest to us that more constant level is better. We lean that way on vitamin D3 also.
  • smokeyjoe
    smokeyjoe Member Posts: 1,425 Member
    Options
    tanstaafl said:

    steady as she goes
    The fundamentals of cimetidine (for more continuous protection against met cells) suggest to us that more constant level is better. We lean that way on vitamin D3 also.

    So, I was at the supplement
    So, I was at the supplement store the other day and went to grab the bottles of the black cumin seed oil, but when I got home I saw I grabbed the wrong stuff as I was in a rush, it's black currant oil.....