American Idol this week

Options
CypressCynthia
CypressCynthia Member Posts: 4,014 Member
in Breast Cancer #1
I thought James and Haley were especially good this week. What do you think AI fans?
«1

Comments

  • Ticky
    Ticky Member Posts: 117
    #2
    Options
    James
    James was my fav. this week. I think Jacob will be sent home.
  • natly15
    natly15 Member Posts: 1,941
    #3
    Options
    James was spectacular this
    James was spectacular this evening. I miss Pia and had hoped Hailey would leave before Pia. I'm still a Casey fan, love Scotty and really enjoy all of them. The talent is the best ever.
  • kim mom of three
    kim mom of three Member Posts: 26
    #4
    Options
    I think they are all great,
    I think they are all great, but I do think its Jacobs turn to leave...I love James. I hope he's the next American Idol
  • disneyfan2008
    disneyfan2008 Member Posts: 6,583 Member
    #5
    Options
    James
    HE has been my favorite since day ONE!

    Denise
  • lizzie17
    lizzie17 Member Posts: 548
    #6
    Options
    James is good, but
    does anyone enjoy the uniqueness of Chase??
  • lizzie17
    lizzie17 Member Posts: 548
    #7
    Options
    James is good, but
    does anyone enjoy the uniqueness of Chase??
  • Gabe N Abby Mom
    Gabe N Abby Mom Member Posts: 2,413
    #8
    Options
    I'm thinking Jacob or Casey
    I'm thinking Jacob or Casey will go home. Casey is very talented, but I'm tired of him growling through all the songs. Jacob has been in the bottom a lot, I think the general public is getting bored with his style.
  • Boppy_of_6
    Boppy_of_6 Member Posts: 1,138
    #9
    Options
    Gabe N Abby Mom said:

    I'm thinking Jacob or Casey
    I'm thinking Jacob or Casey will go home. Casey is very talented, but I'm tired of him growling through all the songs. Jacob has been in the bottom a lot, I think the general public is getting bored with his style.

    I hope its Casey or Hailey
    I am a big Scotty fan and I love Lauren. I do not really like James style of music but he is super talented. I like Jacob too. I liked Casey and Hailey at first but do not care for either now. I would like to see one of them go tonight but I am worried it could be Jacob. There is a great group of talent! God Bless
    (((hugs))) Janice
  • disneyfan2008
    disneyfan2008 Member Posts: 6,583 Member
    #10
    Options
    Boppy_of_6 said:

    I hope its Casey or Hailey
    I am a big Scotty fan and I love Lauren. I do not really like James style of music but he is super talented. I like Jacob too. I liked Casey and Hailey at first but do not care for either now. I would like to see one of them go tonight but I am worried it could be Jacob. There is a great group of talent! God Bless
    (((hugs))) Janice

    going home
    I THINK casey...at this point...time will tell..
  • VickiSam
    VickiSam Member Posts: 9,079 Member
    #11
    Options
    disneyfan2008 said:

    going home
    I THINK casey...at this point...time will tell..

    Rock and Roll -- Queen here .. so James has
    been a favorite of mine from the very beginning. I've enjoy watching James grow stronger and stronger by the week. I do not enjoy Country - so Scotty does not appeal to me -- I do think he will be signing some type of record deal -- as he has a very large voice, and following.

    Haley has a unique voice - I hope she stays around for a few more weeks - which may allow her to flourish vocally.

    Bottom 3 .. Casey, Jacob and Haley ... Going home -- Jacob or Casey


    Vicki Sam
  • cahjah75
    cahjah75 Member Posts: 2,631
    #12
    Options
    I liked
    both of them too. James has been one of my favs since the beginning. Of course, last night I loved hearing the Carol King songs. Brought back a lot of memories :D
    Char
  • Mitzi333
    Mitzi333 Member Posts: 511 Member
    #13
    Options
    cahjah75 said:

    I liked
    both of them too. James has been one of my favs since the beginning. Of course, last night I loved hearing the Carol King songs. Brought back a lot of memories :D
    Char

    James will prob win AI this season...
    Think Jacob or the girl with Curly hair will go home tonight. Although I really like both of them. James has the popularity and he's def a "Show Man".

    Whose going home tonight... Drum Roll please~~~

    Mitzi ;0)
  • disneyfan2008
    disneyfan2008 Member Posts: 6,583 Member
    #14
    Options
    Mitzi333 said:

    James will prob win AI this season...
    Think Jacob or the girl with Curly hair will go home tonight. Although I really like both of them. James has the popularity and he's def a "Show Man".

    Whose going home tonight... Drum Roll please~~~

    Mitzi ;0)

    I think it was time for Casey to GO HOME
    Next I think it will be Jacob...

    I want James to win!!

    Denise
  • lizzie17
    lizzie17 Member Posts: 548
    #15
    Options
    disneyfan2008 said:

    I think it was time for Casey to GO HOME
    Next I think it will be Jacob...

    I want James to win!!

    Denise

    Casey--it was time, but...
    I think he is the all-around most talented musician. He lost sight of who he is.
  • VickiSam
    VickiSam Member Posts: 9,079 Member
    #16
    Options
    lizzie17 said:

    Casey--it was time, but...
    I think he is the all-around most talented musician. He lost sight of who he is.

    Lizzie .. I agree, Casey is extremely talented --
    sad to see him go home before Jacob. Scotty in the bottom 3, right - or did my fever ravished head cold play tricks on me?

    James .. all the way .. Haley not too far behind him .. the rest can go home, and rest up for the summer AI Tour.


    Just my humble opinion.

    Vicki Sam
  • CypressCynthia
    CypressCynthia Member Posts: 4,014 Member
    #17
    Options
    VickiSam said:

    Lizzie .. I agree, Casey is extremely talented --
    sad to see him go home before Jacob. Scotty in the bottom 3, right - or did my fever ravished head cold play tricks on me?

    James .. all the way .. Haley not too far behind him .. the rest can go home, and rest up for the summer AI Tour.


    Just my humble opinion.

    Vicki Sam

    My 2 cents
    Casey is the most talented musician that AI has ever had. The problem with him was that he wasn't a great pop singer and AI does not showcase his type of talent. I knew he would be going home, but I thought Jacob, Lauren or Scotty should go first.

    Jacob's type of singing is not we showcased either and Scotty, I hate to admit this, well I'm over the head tilting, flirty, same old, same old. Lauren is just not ever that memorable to me. I agree with Vicki Sam 100%.
  • natly15
    natly15 Member Posts: 1,941
    #18
    Options
    CypressCynthia said:

    My 2 cents
    Casey is the most talented musician that AI has ever had. The problem with him was that he wasn't a great pop singer and AI does not showcase his type of talent. I knew he would be going home, but I thought Jacob, Lauren or Scotty should go first.

    Jacob's type of singing is not we showcased either and Scotty, I hate to admit this, well I'm over the head tilting, flirty, same old, same old. Lauren is just not ever that memorable to me. I agree with Vicki Sam 100%.

    My 3 cents :)
    I really like Casey and do agree he is a very talented musician and singer. That kid can sing anything, however I was not surprised that he went home. I'm so happy the judges saved him so that he will tour with the group this summer.Lauren has a wonderful voice but she doesnt have the confidence , she is only 16. I'm not a country fan but must admit I really like Scotty. Hailey is sounding better but have never been a fan, wish Pia was there and not Hailey. Jacob has a beautiful voice but I think James will take it all or should. I said from the very beginning that James could very well be the next "Idol". I loved his performance this past week. Talk about being able to sing anything--he has one powerful voice. No matter who wins, hope its not Hailey, they are all winners this year. The judges did a spectacular job of selecting this years talent and I love the "constructive criticism" given by the judges. I dont miss Simon at all, the show has taken a new and uplifting direction. Now that's my 3 cents for today. Hugs :O)
  • Alexis F
    Alexis F Member Posts: 3,598
    #19
    Options
    natly15 said:

    My 3 cents :)
    I really like Casey and do agree he is a very talented musician and singer. That kid can sing anything, however I was not surprised that he went home. I'm so happy the judges saved him so that he will tour with the group this summer.Lauren has a wonderful voice but she doesnt have the confidence , she is only 16. I'm not a country fan but must admit I really like Scotty. Hailey is sounding better but have never been a fan, wish Pia was there and not Hailey. Jacob has a beautiful voice but I think James will take it all or should. I said from the very beginning that James could very well be the next "Idol". I loved his performance this past week. Talk about being able to sing anything--he has one powerful voice. No matter who wins, hope its not Hailey, they are all winners this year. The judges did a spectacular job of selecting this years talent and I love the "constructive criticism" given by the judges. I dont miss Simon at all, the show has taken a new and uplifting direction. Now that's my 3 cents for today. Hugs :O)

    Love Casey!

    Love Casey!
  • disneyfan2008
    disneyfan2008 Member Posts: 6,583 Member
    #20
    Options
    Alexis F said:

    Love Casey!

    Love Casey!

    sorry..i thought it was time for him to go
    LIKE one comment..with all the growls...family dogs dont' vote...

    I CHUCKLED>>

    I am sure he'll go places..
  • disneyfan2008
    disneyfan2008 Member Posts: 6,583 Member
    #21
    Options
    disneyfan2008 said:

    sorry..i thought it was time for him to go
    LIKE one comment..with all the growls...family dogs dont' vote...

    I CHUCKLED>>

    I am sure he'll go places..

    Happy again this week with who was sent home
    Jacob is good singer but I think others were right to stay...I am still rooting for james..

Discussion Boards