If you are stage 1, ER/PR+, HER- and need chemo, can you tell me the reason?

Doing chemo was my own decision
Welcome, Nancy -

I was diagnosed with invasive ductal in one breast, invasive lobular in the other, ER+/PR+/HER2-, stage 1, grade 2. I had 4 tumors total, but very tiny -- none larger than 2 mm. Negative nodes. I had bilateral lumpectomies, followed by chemo, then radiation, and am now on Tamoxifen.

Both my oncologist and a 2nd oncologist who specializes in breast cancer were very much on the fence about whether or not I "needed" to do chemo. My oncologist ran a computer simulation that estimated that chemo would decrease my chances of recurrence by 3-4%, and that was enough for me -- I said, sign me up.

Many women have the OncotypeDX test done, which estimates how effective chemo would be on your particular tumor. I was offered the Oncotype test, but refused it, because I had already made the decision that I wanted to do chemo.

For me the main reason for my decision was that I couldn't live with myself if I didn't do chemo, the cancer returned later, and I was left thinking, what if I'd done chemo? Hitting it with everything I could was the right decision for my own peace of mind.

Don't know if that helps, but do keep us posted on your oncologist visit?

Traci

tumor grade
My sister's stats were the same as yours and she did have chemo, but it was her choice. It is possibly the grade 3 that is worrying your onc as this means that the cells look less like normal cells and multiply faster. But, when in doubt, it is your right to seek out a second opinion.

See:
Tumor Grade

Boppy_of_6 said:

I did chemo too
I was dx'd with stage 1 grade 1 IDC ER/PR+ HER- I had a lumpectomy, 3 nodes removed all clear and clear margins.Tumor was right at 1 cm. I did 4 rounds of Cytoxan and Taxotere, followed by 30 rads and I am now on Tamoxifen. My Onc. recommended I do chemo because of my age, I turned 49 right after dx. They kept saying because you are so young. I went with the chemo because I wanted to know I had done everything I could possibly do to beat the beast. God Bless
(((hugs))) Janice

yes I was thinking the same
yes I was thinking the same thing as CC

Susiestn said:

Walking in your shoes
Same stats and onc score of 17. I'm 45 years old and have 9 year old twin girls. I start chemo (my decision) next week. Couldn't live wondering everyday if I did enough to make sure this doesn't return! I'm scared to death about what's ahead but I don't ever want to say "if I only had..." Good luck to you and I know how hard a decision this is!

I was Stage 1, grade 2, 1cm,
I was Stage 1, grade 2, 1cm, IDC, clean nodes, clean margins, ER+ PR+. My oncotype score was 12. My onco said he didn't think I needed to have chemo because it would only improve my prognosis by a couple of percentage points. I had partial-breast radiation 2x/day for 5 days. I've been on Tamoxifen since August.

Katmy said:

My cancer diagnosis is
My cancer diagnosis is similar. I am small chested so we were advised to have a radical mastectomy. I did.
Because my margins were not clear, I immediately went to radiation.
Now, I am doing 4 rounds of Taxotere and Cytoxin. It increases my odds of cure by a small margin, but one worth taking. All medical people advising me said, "you get this one chance at a cure. If you don't do chemo now and the cancer shows up else where, the chemo may be much less successful. Better to prevent matastisis." So I followed their advice.

I was Stage 1 and didn't
I was Stage 1 and didn't have chemo. The %, according to the stats, was that chemo would only help about 2% and that was not worth it to me. You need to take your advice of your oncologist and decide for yourself.


Good luck!

TraciInLA said:

Doing chemo was my own decision
Welcome, Nancy -

I was diagnosed with invasive ductal in one breast, invasive lobular in the other, ER+/PR+/HER2-, stage 1, grade 2. I had 4 tumors total, but very tiny -- none larger than 2 mm. Negative nodes. I had bilateral lumpectomies, followed by chemo, then radiation, and am now on Tamoxifen.

Both my oncologist and a 2nd oncologist who specializes in breast cancer were very much on the fence about whether or not I "needed" to do chemo. My oncologist ran a computer simulation that estimated that chemo would decrease my chances of recurrence by 3-4%, and that was enough for me -- I said, sign me up.

Many women have the OncotypeDX test done, which estimates how effective chemo would be on your particular tumor. I was offered the Oncotype test, but refused it, because I had already made the decision that I wanted to do chemo.

For me the main reason for my decision was that I couldn't live with myself if I didn't do chemo, the cancer returned later, and I was left thinking, what if I'd done chemo? Hitting it with everything I could was the right decision for my own peace of mind.

Don't know if that helps, but do keep us posted on your oncologist visit?

Traci

i am so lost on this lingo
other then treatments... ER+/PR+/HER2-, stage 1, grade 2. I had 4 tumors total, but very tiny -- none larger than 2 mm. Negative nodes I have never heard any of this with my treatment just over 3 yrs ago...


I just am told labs good now etc..no clue what it was when I started..margins etc...

I should be more informed I GUESS after reading so many who know exact details...

Denise

csr771 said:

OncotypeDX - 22
I was stage 1, no node involvment, IDC 9cm, non-aggressive, hormone receptive cancer, DX Nov, 2010. I had a mastectomy in January and immedate recostruction. I go the results of the oncotype DX test last week. My onco would have liked the score to be around 18, but it was 22. I have a 10% chance of recurrence in the next 10 years and chemo would have only reduced the percentage of recurrence by 1 or 2%. My breast surgeon, prior to my seeing the onco, had said that I would more than likely need chemo, but the Onco said that if I was one of hs family members he wouldn't recommend it. My options would have been chemo plus Arimidex or Arimidex only. I am on Arimidex only.

bumping up
,,,,,

BioAdoptMom said:

Thank you all so much for
Thank you all so much for your additional comments, advice and wisdom! I am pretty sure based on all this info, plus what I have read, that if the onco tells me on Wednesday that chemo will increase my long term survival rates by at least 3 percentage points I will go for it! I have an 11 y/o DD and two young adult sons and would love to increase my chances of being around for college graduations, weddings and grandchildren!

Thanks again!

Nancy

Good luck with your
Good luck with your appointment Nancy and good luck with chemo if you decide to do it, based on your oncologist's opinion.


Hugs, Angie

Angie2U said:

Good luck with your
Good luck with your appointment Nancy and good luck with chemo if you decide to do it, based on your oncologist's opinion.


Hugs, Angie

I am stage 1 grade 2 ER/PR +, Her2-, Chemo is recommended
I am a 47yr and pre-menopausal. I was diagnosed 1/27/11 with ILC, further testing revealed multiple locations in the same breast of invasive lobular carcinoma. Tumors were 1.2cm, .8cm, and .5cm. I had 0/7 nodes positive. I am BRAC 1&2-, Oncotypedx score 25. I had a bilateral mastectomy with reconstruction started on 3/2. Today was my first appt. with the Oncologist. His recommendation is 4 doses of TC every 3 weeks, followed by Tamoxifen for 5 years, based on the fact that together the tumors represented 2.5 cm of cancer. He stated that Oncotype score just solidified his feelings that I would benefit from chemo. I had really hoped not to need chemo. Although I want to do everything I can to make sure this doesn't come back, I am afraid. My mother had breast cancer, which was much more invasive than mine. She participated in a clinical trial in 1994, and recieved high doses of AC. Unfortunately she developed AML,(leukemia) 2 yrs after her chemo treatment. I know first hand that chemo has risks, but I am hoping to decide what to do this weekend.