Port or Picc?

JanJan63
JanJan63 Member Posts: 2,478 Member

I've been having problems with not absorbing magnesium. My onc says it's due to the chemo and is not uncommon. They've been giving me additional magnesium by IV right after the chemo every two weeks. This last time my magnesium got so low that they're calling it critical and had paramedice cme by the house this morning to give me an IV of megnesium rather than wait until my chemo tomorrow. I take pills every day but they don't abosrb very well.

They couldn't get an IV in me. Five tries and they finally gave up. My veins keep blowing. They're weak, rolling, small, valvey, and it seems that no matter what I do I'm dehydrated. So I'm a very hard start.

They had to speak to my onc and tell him they couldn't do it and confirm that it can be done tomorrow. He called me after and said they're going to do the magnesium once a week now. He wants me to consider gatting another port or picc line. I've had both. The port was rejected by my body and eventually started coming out on it's own. The picc line was uncomfortable. Both were uncomfortable all the time, actually. I found that the huge needle they use for the port was painful and a number of times it clogged and was difficult and just a pain in the butt. Plus you have to go get it flushed regularly.

I'm curious what you all think? Do you prefer one over the other?  And why? Thank you!

Jan

«1

Comments

  • JanJan63
    JanJan63 Member Posts: 2,478 Member
    Just got another call from my

    Just got another call from my onc. Chemo is now off until the magnesum is under control. Perfect. I'm going on a trip on April 20 and don't want to go anywhere with my alligator skin and creepy rash. The way it was set up I should have been much improved by then. The chemo makes me sun sensitive, too. Dammit, why does everything always seen to go south for me?

    The plus side is that my most recent CEA is down to 7. But why can't I get past the 4 treatment mark? Ugh...

    Feeling very sorry for myelf right now. I know things are much worse for some otjer people on here but this is disheartening.

    Jan

  • Twinzma
    Twinzma Member Posts: 236 Member
    Port I think

    I have seen more infections with Picc lines that I have with the ports. While the port though is more invassive, I would really be concerned with an infection in your weakened immune system. Not that I have a ton of recent experience, I did work in the medical field in the 90's so I know things have likely changed greatly, but even my friend with Hodgkins lymphoma had to have several removed and replaced recently. My dad's did as well just a few years back. 

     

  • abita
    abita Member Posts: 1,152 Member
    Did you get a prescription

    Did you get a prescription for Lidocaine for your port? If I put it on with the correct timing, I can't even feel the needle when they access my port. 

  • myAZmountain
    myAZmountain Member Posts: 417 Member
    3 ports in 6 months

    So sorry to hear about your issue with the Magnesioum-dang you need a break! I had issues with ports--but it was from the use of dissolvable stitches that coused abcess twice, the Interventional  Radiologist was too egotistical to beleive it was due to the stitches--the third placement was rough and he went into the axillary vein instead of subclavian, but did use glue to close so no more abscess, just a huge blood clot from neck to elbow! I have since learned that blood clots are quite common with cancer/chemo/ports. Even after all that, I would still rather a port than a PICC line I think.  Hope so much you find the right IV acess without much pain and hardship! Love the pic and your horse is gorgeous!

  • Annabelle41415
    Annabelle41415 Member Posts: 6,742 Member
    Port

    I'm so sorry you have now experienced another setback with the mag being out of wack.  If they didn't give you a cream of lidocain to put on your port before insertion than I'm wondering why not.  Just put the cream on 1 hour before infusion, cover it with a big bandaid and you don't even feel the needle going in.  It's a prescription not OTC.  So hoping that you can still go on vacation and enjoy yourself.  A port also needs to be flushed and I'm sure your treatment center has done that, but it's very important.

    Kim

  • feckcancer
    feckcancer Member Posts: 189 Member
    just wondering if you have

    just wondering if you have tried the epsom salts foot soaks and/or baths to absorb some magnesium that way. Also you can buy magnesium oils which the body absorbs too. i don't know if it absorbs better through the skin but might be worth a try if you haven't already

  • Trubrit
    Trubrit Member Posts: 5,796 Member
    Port

    I would say port, but that is only because I have never had a pic line. 

    Flushing is no problem. Just the inconvenience of going to the hospital to get it done.  But you only get your line flushed once a month, if the port is not being used.  I think our friend, Dave, has gone in at even longer intervals, but that isn't recommended. Plus, with your track history, I would go in when they tell you to.  BUT, if you are getting your port accessed regularly, then you won't need to get it flushed. They do that before infusion. 

    If you choose a port, then I would have a good talk with the surgeon, and ask why he thinks your other one popped out and if he thinks it will happen again.  If he said yes, then I would think that would be my decisoin made, and go with the pic. 

    Ah, decisions!  Our life is filled with constant decisions. 

    Good luck, Jan.

    Tru

  • JanJan63
    JanJan63 Member Posts: 2,478 Member
    Thanks for the input everyone

    Thanks for the input everyone. I really just do not want to do either. Physically they both sucked and I had Lidocaine and found that it made no difference whatsoever, is it possible it doesn't work for me? I still see myself marching up and down the hallway like a German soldier to try to get the line open so they could give me my chemo in it, feeling like a fool and angry about it. This was after spending 20 minutes coughing as hard as I could, holding my arms in different positions, all that crap. The port was just not overly helpful to me.

    If I remember right the PICC line had yo be cared for carefully. I had it for about a week but I can't imagine having one long term.

    One of the things that bothers me is that I hate having visible evidence of the cancer. I'm used to the ostomy bag but having a creepy line in my arm or a big lump on my chest is something that mentally I just do not want.

    I think I'm going to talk to my oncologist about just stopping the chemo for now. Maybe four is just my limit. I'll be doing it twice a year and maybe four will just have to be the protocal. I feel rather defeated. I was determined to do all six this time. Four is the most I've ever gotten through before things went south. But it's not up to me. I feel great and am so much stronger than I was. I'm pushing towards, dare I say it, normal. 

    Thank you all!

    Jan

  • JanJan63
    JanJan63 Member Posts: 2,478 Member
    Oh, I forgot. Twinzma, I'm on

    Oh, I forgot. Twinzma, I'm on an immunotherapy chemo which is not really chemo so my immune system is fine. No worrying about bacteria or any of those things any more than normal.

    And MyAZmountain, thanks for your words about my horse. The picture is from before I had cancer so it's about 6 years old but I love it. He's giving me a hug. He does that. The last time I saw him I stood beside his shoulder and he put his nack and head around me and stood like that for a couple of minutes. We've had him for almsot 20 years. He's my baby.

    Jan

  • myAZmountain
    myAZmountain Member Posts: 417 Member
    JanJan63 said:

    Oh, I forgot. Twinzma, I'm on

    Oh, I forgot. Twinzma, I'm on an immunotherapy chemo which is not really chemo so my immune system is fine. No worrying about bacteria or any of those things any more than normal.

    And MyAZmountain, thanks for your words about my horse. The picture is from before I had cancer so it's about 6 years old but I love it. He's giving me a hug. He does that. The last time I saw him I stood beside his shoulder and he put his nack and head around me and stood like that for a couple of minutes. We've had him for almsot 20 years. He's my baby.

    Jan

    Horses=Healing

    Love that he is hugging you! When I was first diagnosed last year and had emergency surgery I recuperated at my daughter's school where she works--it is an all girls boarding school renowned for its Equestrian program...Walking up to the barn and visiting all of the beautiful horses was a huge part of my recovery process... giving them treats and petting their noses. So I equate horses with healing and love!

  • abita
    abita Member Posts: 1,152 Member
    JanJan63 said:

    Thanks for the input everyone

    Thanks for the input everyone. I really just do not want to do either. Physically they both sucked and I had Lidocaine and found that it made no difference whatsoever, is it possible it doesn't work for me? I still see myself marching up and down the hallway like a German soldier to try to get the line open so they could give me my chemo in it, feeling like a fool and angry about it. This was after spending 20 minutes coughing as hard as I could, holding my arms in different positions, all that crap. The port was just not overly helpful to me.

    If I remember right the PICC line had yo be cared for carefully. I had it for about a week but I can't imagine having one long term.

    One of the things that bothers me is that I hate having visible evidence of the cancer. I'm used to the ostomy bag but having a creepy line in my arm or a big lump on my chest is something that mentally I just do not want.

    I think I'm going to talk to my oncologist about just stopping the chemo for now. Maybe four is just my limit. I'll be doing it twice a year and maybe four will just have to be the protocal. I feel rather defeated. I was determined to do all six this time. Four is the most I've ever gotten through before things went south. But it's not up to me. I feel great and am so much stronger than I was. I'm pushing towards, dare I say it, normal. 

    Thank you all!

    Jan

    timing is everything with the

    timing is everything with the Lidocaine. Too early and it no longer works, too late and it doesn't work yet.

     

  • beaumontdave
    beaumontdave Member Posts: 1,280 Member
    The port is all I know and

    The port is all I know and after the course of chemo it went as long as two months between flushes, before being ignored for a few years, then removed at the last liver surgery. Had to have it stripped once to clear the end in the vein, a "vein snake" from my groin upward. That was annoying, but the only other issues were trips to the ER when the connectors twisted apart during work. They had to make a new needle and line to the connector, as it clogs right up. I learned to tape the connectors after that. The port did it's job, and having it anywhere else but my chest would have been really limiting. Needles were and are a pain since my veins are rollers too, if I had to do it again, I'd pick the port. Hope you find what works for you Jan......................................Dave

  • OnTheRoad
    OnTheRoad Member Posts: 31 Member
    Port rejection can be an issue

    Hello, JanJan

    I finished my 12th session of Folfox abou a month ago. The port worked fine for me but the nurse once said not everybody has a good experience with it.

    She told me 2 stories about other patients that also had their bodies rejecting the port. In one of the patients, the rejection was so strong that the port was starting to surface on the outer skin due to rejection. She also told me they tried to remove the port and install a new one in the other side of the chest, just to have the same rejection results there also.

    Maybe if your body rejected the first port it will also reject a possible new one.... I think this is a possibility....

    BTW, I also hate any type of things in my body that reminds me about the cancer. I even did not liked to wash too much the port side of my chest just to not touch it and remember how bad I felt sometimes during chemo.

  • Annabelle41415
    Annabelle41415 Member Posts: 6,742 Member
    abita said:

    timing is everything with the

    timing is everything with the Lidocaine. Too early and it no longer works, too late and it doesn't work yet.

     

    Agree

    With lidocaine you need to apply it liberally and then put a bandage on it so it doesn't rub off before the needle is inserted and only about 45 minutes before.  Early or late, Abita is right, it doesn't work.  Hated the lump in my chest as well from the port as it hurt hugging my kids, husband, dad, etc as I'm think at it poked through so far. 

    Kim

  • Canadian Sandy
    Canadian Sandy Member Posts: 783 Member
    I haven’t had either so can’t

    I haven’t had either so can’t help much. I did have quite a few magnesium drips the time I lost my electrolytes. I hate to find your having more problems. Good luck Jan!

  • JanJan63
    JanJan63 Member Posts: 2,478 Member
    OnTheRoad said:

    Port rejection can be an issue

    Hello, JanJan

    I finished my 12th session of Folfox abou a month ago. The port worked fine for me but the nurse once said not everybody has a good experience with it.

    She told me 2 stories about other patients that also had their bodies rejecting the port. In one of the patients, the rejection was so strong that the port was starting to surface on the outer skin due to rejection. She also told me they tried to remove the port and install a new one in the other side of the chest, just to have the same rejection results there also.

    Maybe if your body rejected the first port it will also reject a possible new one.... I think this is a possibility....

    BTW, I also hate any type of things in my body that reminds me about the cancer. I even did not liked to wash too much the port side of my chest just to not touch it and remember how bad I felt sometimes during chemo.

    It took about a year for it

    It took about a year for it to happen but that's what mine did. Two of the three little bumps came through the skin and were bleeding. I agree, it would probably happen again.

    Welcome to the forum!

    Jan

  • JanJan63
    JanJan63 Member Posts: 2,478 Member
    I had the magnesium yesterday

    I had the magnesium yesterday. They got the IV in on the first try. I don't want a port or a PICC so they can just deal with me. I think I'm going to suggest that I just have four treatments each tme, not six. It'll be twice a year so that ought to be enough. We'll see what he says. That would mean that I'm done this time around. Which would be wonderful. My skin is really taking a beating and I'd be happy to have a break for a while. I feel so good these days its wonderful. I'm so happy to be able to do things for myself and clean my own house and do my own laundry. I did 5 loads the other day and went up and down to the basement each time. I hadn't been down there in months due to being too weak for the stairs.

    The medical people I've dealt with over the past few days have been acting like I'm going to drop dead from the low magfnesium and it's been scary because of that but I feel fine. I think I might manage to go see my horse today, even. The weather has warmed up a bit and I miss him so much!

    Jan

  • JanJan63
    JanJan63 Member Posts: 2,478 Member

    Horses=Healing

    Love that he is hugging you! When I was first diagnosed last year and had emergency surgery I recuperated at my daughter's school where she works--it is an all girls boarding school renowned for its Equestrian program...Walking up to the barn and visiting all of the beautiful horses was a huge part of my recovery process... giving them treats and petting their noses. So I equate horses with healing and love!

    Do you live in Arizona? I'm

    Do you live in Arizona? I'm going to Phoenix and possibly Sedona in April. I'm wondering what the weather will be like? First trip anywhere in 7 years!!

    Jan

  • Twinzma
    Twinzma Member Posts: 236 Member
    Your Horse is Beautiful Jan

    What kind is he? My friends just got a new addition just a week following a horrible loss of thier 2year old. He really is amazing! His Blood line is from Bold Ruler (Secretariat's sire) and Native Dancer. You would think that with his genes he would have been an amazing race horse but no....They ended up renaming him Molasses before he left the track and went into the police academy. Rigorous training, but still too slow so that's how my friends acquired him. Only 8 and on his 3rd home already....It's a sin but he is adapting very well to his new home. Their other horse though is not liking it too much yet, it's an Arabian and stubborn, but in time they will stop snorting at each other....I hope! Almost 16 hands, amazing! I keep telling Jim I want one, but no.......We live in an equestrian neighborhood, so he says I can see all the horses I want! lol Oh well maybe one day he will change his mind. 

  • JanJan63
    JanJan63 Member Posts: 2,478 Member
    Twinzma said:

    Your Horse is Beautiful Jan

    What kind is he? My friends just got a new addition just a week following a horrible loss of thier 2year old. He really is amazing! His Blood line is from Bold Ruler (Secretariat's sire) and Native Dancer. You would think that with his genes he would have been an amazing race horse but no....They ended up renaming him Molasses before he left the track and went into the police academy. Rigorous training, but still too slow so that's how my friends acquired him. Only 8 and on his 3rd home already....It's a sin but he is adapting very well to his new home. Their other horse though is not liking it too much yet, it's an Arabian and stubborn, but in time they will stop snorting at each other....I hope! Almost 16 hands, amazing! I keep telling Jim I want one, but no.......We live in an equestrian neighborhood, so he says I can see all the horses I want! lol Oh well maybe one day he will change his mind. 

    You need a horse! You can't

    You need a horse! You can't live in that area and not have one! That's sad!

    There was a thoroughbred where we used to board that was the same. Gorgeous gray guy but had no heart for running. He's learning to jump now. My guy is half quarter horse going back to Stromy Frost and a quarter thoroughbred and a quarter morgan. He has the morgan body so he's solid and chunky. I rode him this afternoon for the first time in about 8 or 9 months. He was perfect as always. He's such a good boy, I'm so lucky to have him. It felt so good to be on his back but my daughter had to put his saddle on. I have little strength to carry it let alone raise it above my head. It was even a struggle to get on from the mounting block. But once I was up there it was heaven. We just walked and trotted a bit for maybe half an hour but I feel like a million bucks now. 

    Jan