Article from Dr. Lenz

24

Comments

  • Buckwirth
    Buckwirth Member Posts: 1,258 Member
    Love2Cats said:

    Great article Lisa
    I just had to discontinue my Avastin, because it probably caused the blood clot(s)that I am dealing with now. I have had my resection surgery, so now I feel better about having to stop the Avastin, and just continue on with Folfox.

    Regarding the controversy on the boards, I tend to not like negativity either, and at first I did get that feeling from Blake, but after I got used to the way that he speaks, I don't perceive him as meaning to purposefully come off as negative. He just is very direct when he speaks, doesn't sugar coat anything, and that is just his style/nature. I personally would rather gather as much information from both sides, in order to make a more educated choice. But, still I do understand why people perceive it as negativity, because I for quite awhile I did too.

    When I first started reading his posts, he instantly reminded me of a cartoon character named "Glum" from the Gullivers Travels cartoon...you know that guy that always said "we'll never make it" Here is a snippet from the cartoon for those of you who never saw it. Blake I hope you are not offended, it is all in good fun.


    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uqALm_rmM1g&NR=1

    Loved it
    And my style is direct, though I try to add a bit of sugar from time to time ;)

    I want an oncologist that tells me my odds of living 5 years is are about 10%, but if we do x we can raise those odds to 15%. Be honest, don't sell me hope. Recently I had a discussion about quality of life with my Onc. Should I be blessed to reach NED was it better to do mop-up, in the hope of buying an extra 6 months, or to take a break and spend my gained time now. What good is an extra 6 months if it is all spent in treatment?

    He actually got a little excited. Most of his patients don't want to have that conversation. Front end vs back end and quality of life. It was a good talk.

    So, thanks for posting the Gulliver reference.

    Blake
  • Kathleen808
    Kathleen808 Member Posts: 2,342 Member
    Dr Lenz
    Hi Lisa,
    We talked to Dr. Lenz about this at ****'s appointment on Monday. He basically said the same thing as the article. That both Avastin and Erbitux are often effective in metastasized disease but not Stage 3 disease. He said that they don't know why yet but that is what the research shows.

    Thinking of you and always praying for you.

    Aloha,
    Kathleen
  • tanstaafl
    tanstaafl Member Posts: 1,313 Member
    Buckwirth said:

    Lisa
    Do we or don't want to look at the research? Should everything anyone says be taken at face value? How is that "using your brains"?

    One user posted the benefits of Turmeric, and said that it was a booster for chemo. Sloan-Kettering points out that the current recommendation is that Turmeric should not be used when in Chemo.

    What was the the source for the original poster? That Turmeric can have a boosting effect for chemos no longer in use because their side effects outweighed their benefits, and that by being able to use those particular chemo agents in lower doses with turmeric maybe they could be brought back. It was a chemical specific test, and saying that it applied to all chemotherapy agents was irresponsible.

    The number one cause of Cancer in the first world today? Obesity. So a better diet is to be commended, and eating healthy will do no harm.

    I am sorry that you find contrary information disturbing, but we cannot just say everything works, and if someone asks a question it is fair to get answers from both sides if there is some kind of controversy.

    Here is what I will promise. I won't put up anything that I do not personally believe to be solid fact. I won't question science where the science is not questionable. In this case biology is, well, biology. I don't make this stuff up, the body works the way it works.

    Have I ever told someone to stop what they were doing (exception- where it can cause current harm such as turmeric)? Have I called anyone names or passed judgement on them? I know I have asked that some give credit to their surgeons, but I never saw that as passing judgement, and I can tell you that whole post was me blowing steam about a user who does not have CRC but comes here often with what I consider to be really bad advice.

    Hope that helps, and I hope you don't hate me for doing just this: "use your brains and follow your hearts!"

    pharma phriendly overgeneralizations, excusitis
    "Turmeric should not be used when in Chemo"
    Sounds like dangerously overgeneralized advice. Even if turmeric were shown by actual trial to be conflicted with some particular oxidative poison, like platinum, that result could not be logically extended to 5FUs, gemacitabine, irinotecan, RTK inhibitors, beta glucans, or several HIF, VEGF, COX2, EGF and platelet inhibitors.

    My contempt grows for organizations that bend over backwards to accomodate disasterous pharmaceutical side effects and contraindications for expensive drug souffles, while supposedly stumbling and stuck dead by the simplest supplement consideration that can even be found anywhere, even if irrelevant.
  • smokeyjoe
    smokeyjoe Member Posts: 1,425 Member
    Buckwirth said:

    Loved it
    And my style is direct, though I try to add a bit of sugar from time to time ;)

    I want an oncologist that tells me my odds of living 5 years is are about 10%, but if we do x we can raise those odds to 15%. Be honest, don't sell me hope. Recently I had a discussion about quality of life with my Onc. Should I be blessed to reach NED was it better to do mop-up, in the hope of buying an extra 6 months, or to take a break and spend my gained time now. What good is an extra 6 months if it is all spent in treatment?

    He actually got a little excited. Most of his patients don't want to have that conversation. Front end vs back end and quality of life. It was a good talk.

    So, thanks for posting the Gulliver reference.

    Blake

    Just wondering where you
    Just wondering where you have mets now?? Have you had new mets pop up or are they basically in the same place when you were first diagnosed??
  • Nana b
    Nana b Member Posts: 3,030 Member

    Dr Lenz
    Hi Lisa,
    We talked to Dr. Lenz about this at ****'s appointment on Monday. He basically said the same thing as the article. That both Avastin and Erbitux are often effective in metastasized disease but not Stage 3 disease. He said that they don't know why yet but that is what the research shows.

    Thinking of you and always praying for you.

    Aloha,
    Kathleen

    I believe people who believe
    I believe people who believe in the use of supplements should be able to exchange ideas without someone coming on and rebutting everything one says. Just let those that want to share information have their conversations. Pleas feel free to ask a question or share information. Just don't say that it's all *******,
  • lisa42
    lisa42 Member Posts: 3,625 Member
    smokeyjoe said:

    Just wondering where you
    Just wondering where you have mets now?? Have you had new mets pop up or are they basically in the same place when you were first diagnosed??

    Me?
    Smokeyjoe,

    I think you are asking me- I have had new mets in my liver and lungs along the way- I had my liver resected in May '08 & now I have 4 spots in my liver so, yes, I have had new mets pop up. I also had a recurrence in my rectum at the original tumor site. I have not, however, had new tumors pop up in any new sites since my original diagnosis. It was already profusely throughout my liver and lungs upon my diagnosis in Aug. '07.

    Lisa
  • smokeyjoe
    smokeyjoe Member Posts: 1,425 Member
    lisa42 said:

    Me?
    Smokeyjoe,

    I think you are asking me- I have had new mets in my liver and lungs along the way- I had my liver resected in May '08 & now I have 4 spots in my liver so, yes, I have had new mets pop up. I also had a recurrence in my rectum at the original tumor site. I have not, however, had new tumors pop up in any new sites since my original diagnosis. It was already profusely throughout my liver and lungs upon my diagnosis in Aug. '07.

    Lisa

    Thanks for all your
    Thanks for all your information Lisa, (actually both Lisa's) you are TRULY an inspiration. I'm still trying to wrap my head around all of this :( So, far I have no mets to lung or liver that show up on CT scans, hopefully the chemo is working and I will remain this way.
  • plh4gail
    plh4gail Member Posts: 1,238 Member
    Hmmm.....love and hugs to
    Hmmm.....love and hugs to you Lisa!....your Central Cali buddy, Gail

    P.S. you hang in there like a trooper!!
  • Buckwirth
    Buckwirth Member Posts: 1,258 Member
    Nana b said:

    I believe people who believe
    I believe people who believe in the use of supplements should be able to exchange ideas without someone coming on and rebutting everything one says. Just let those that want to share information have their conversations. Pleas feel free to ask a question or share information. Just don't say that it's all *******,

    If you re read my posts
    You will see that is exactly what I did. I even posted information saying it was beneficial.

    Not sure what word you used (CSN automatically * certain words) but I did not use it.

    For those using urine to check blood PH:

    Next time you are getting a blood test, ask for PH levels. See if they match what you believe they are.

    Btw,

    How was Disneyland?
  • Nana b
    Nana b Member Posts: 3,030 Member
    Buckwirth said:

    If you re read my posts
    You will see that is exactly what I did. I even posted information saying it was beneficial.

    Not sure what word you used (CSN automatically * certain words) but I did not use it.

    For those using urine to check blood PH:

    Next time you are getting a blood test, ask for PH levels. See if they match what you believe they are.

    Btw,

    How was Disneyland?

    Wasn't pointing a
    Wasn't pointing a finger...

    Disneyland was fantastic! We had a great time! Thanks
  • smokeyjoe
    smokeyjoe Member Posts: 1,425 Member
    plh4gail said:

    Hmmm.....love and hugs to
    Hmmm.....love and hugs to you Lisa!....your Central Cali buddy, Gail

    P.S. you hang in there like a trooper!!

    How do you deal with your
    How do you deal with your feelings when all seems so overwhelming.... I'm putting together a gift for a friend, drink tray with coasters where you insert your own personal photos....doing this project, printing the photos, I got overwhelmed, and started to cry uncontrollably, memories from before all this mess, happy carefree days all gone .....feel like I'm having an anxiety attack....this was something I purchased to give her for x-mas, we were supposed to meet for dinner but I ended up in hospital and the diagnosis. Now, moving forward seems so hopeless. Physically I feel wonderful, look great, no one would know I am ill. Mentally I feel I just cannot cope!!!
  • Buckwirth
    Buckwirth Member Posts: 1,258 Member
    smokeyjoe said:

    Just wondering where you
    Just wondering where you have mets now?? Have you had new mets pop up or are they basically in the same place when you were first diagnosed??

    If it was me
    My last scan showed great improvement at most of my lymph sites, but my original tumor and one lymph lit up the scan.

    Long story short, on 1-10 they took out the rectum and gave me a permanent colostomy.

    Since then, no treatment and no scans. Next scan is May, treatment decisions to follow.
  • smokeyjoe
    smokeyjoe Member Posts: 1,425 Member
    Buckwirth said:

    If it was me
    My last scan showed great improvement at most of my lymph sites, but my original tumor and one lymph lit up the scan.

    Long story short, on 1-10 they took out the rectum and gave me a permanent colostomy.

    Since then, no treatment and no scans. Next scan is May, treatment decisions to follow.

    Wow, that seems like a long
    Wow, that seems like a long time inbetween scans and treatment.....I thought they did scans every three months....
  • Buckwirth
    Buckwirth Member Posts: 1,258 Member
    Nana b said:

    Wasn't pointing a
    Wasn't pointing a finger...

    Disneyland was fantastic! We had a great time! Thanks

    I grew up
    A few miles away. Used to watch the fireworks from our front lawn in the summer.

    Did you make it to the beach? I know the weather was a little cool, but even in winter our coast can be beautiful.
  • lisa42
    lisa42 Member Posts: 3,625 Member
    smokeyjoe said:

    How do you deal with your
    How do you deal with your feelings when all seems so overwhelming.... I'm putting together a gift for a friend, drink tray with coasters where you insert your own personal photos....doing this project, printing the photos, I got overwhelmed, and started to cry uncontrollably, memories from before all this mess, happy carefree days all gone .....feel like I'm having an anxiety attack....this was something I purchased to give her for x-mas, we were supposed to meet for dinner but I ended up in hospital and the diagnosis. Now, moving forward seems so hopeless. Physically I feel wonderful, look great, no one would know I am ill. Mentally I feel I just cannot cope!!!

    coping- Smokeyjoe
    Hi,

    Coping with all that having a cancer diagnosis entails isn't easy. It doesn't really seem to matter what stage a person is- I know someone who was stage I but was completely devastated and fell apart upon her diagnosis. I will not be one to judge someone based upon how bad or good their outcome is supposed to be. We are all different and we react to things differently. Some people even have a delayed reaction a ways down the cancer road. How do I personally cope? Well, like I said, it's not easy, but I do talk to a lot of people. I can't tell you how much coming here on the CSN site has helped me. Also, I have met some friends- a couple through CSN and a couple just through other people- & these women all have my same kind of cancer. We talk on the phone a lot and email back and forth. Nothing is taboo to talk about- we talk about it all- all that is involved with cancer, chemo, plus also about our families, feelings, and other people around us.
    You need someone to talk with- someone who really has been there.
    If you haven't discovered anyone from CSN who lives near you, I'd start there & hopefully you will hit it off.
    Going to a counselor is also something I've done. I admit I would have liked to talk with a counselor more than I have, but I'm always so busy with my regular dr. appts and all the activities and appts my three kids have, that it doesn't leave a lot of time for me. It is important to carve out time for dealing with your feelings- I am learning that!

    I don't know what your situation is with regards to family, how many people you have around you, etc. I would say to get involved in something if you're not- whether it's an exercise class, a community center class for fun (whatever your interest is), volunteering somewhere, etc. Something to get your mind off cancer and also feel good about yourself in that maybe you're helping others. Do you currently work?

    Whatever you do, do something for yourself that is fun and makes you feel good & definitely plug in with a counselor and/or local support group, and also plug in with other people who "have been there". & keep coming back here!

    Take care!!
    Lisa
  • AnneCan
    AnneCan Member Posts: 3,673 Member
    Lisa
    Thanks for sharing this interesting letter. I hope they do get to the bottom of all this AND SOON!
  • smokeyjoe
    smokeyjoe Member Posts: 1,425 Member
    lisa42 said:

    coping- Smokeyjoe
    Hi,

    Coping with all that having a cancer diagnosis entails isn't easy. It doesn't really seem to matter what stage a person is- I know someone who was stage I but was completely devastated and fell apart upon her diagnosis. I will not be one to judge someone based upon how bad or good their outcome is supposed to be. We are all different and we react to things differently. Some people even have a delayed reaction a ways down the cancer road. How do I personally cope? Well, like I said, it's not easy, but I do talk to a lot of people. I can't tell you how much coming here on the CSN site has helped me. Also, I have met some friends- a couple through CSN and a couple just through other people- & these women all have my same kind of cancer. We talk on the phone a lot and email back and forth. Nothing is taboo to talk about- we talk about it all- all that is involved with cancer, chemo, plus also about our families, feelings, and other people around us.
    You need someone to talk with- someone who really has been there.
    If you haven't discovered anyone from CSN who lives near you, I'd start there & hopefully you will hit it off.
    Going to a counselor is also something I've done. I admit I would have liked to talk with a counselor more than I have, but I'm always so busy with my regular dr. appts and all the activities and appts my three kids have, that it doesn't leave a lot of time for me. It is important to carve out time for dealing with your feelings- I am learning that!

    I don't know what your situation is with regards to family, how many people you have around you, etc. I would say to get involved in something if you're not- whether it's an exercise class, a community center class for fun (whatever your interest is), volunteering somewhere, etc. Something to get your mind off cancer and also feel good about yourself in that maybe you're helping others. Do you currently work?

    Whatever you do, do something for yourself that is fun and makes you feel good & definitely plug in with a counselor and/or local support group, and also plug in with other people who "have been there". & keep coming back here!

    Take care!!
    Lisa

    Well, went out for nice
    Well, went out for nice dinner with lifelong friends tonight.....my girlfriend told me another close friend of hers was just diagnosed with colon cancer and she basically had the same surgery as me.....so, now my friend has booked herself for a colonoscopy :) With two people close to her having the same cancer got her thinking, good thing she's now getting herself checked.
  • Buckwirth
    Buckwirth Member Posts: 1,258 Member
    smokeyjoe said:

    Wow, that seems like a long
    Wow, that seems like a long time inbetween scans and treatment.....I thought they did scans every three months....

    Normally
    My surgical wound is only really healing now, and I am scheduled for a trip to Europe mid May, so we decided the best time for the scan is just before leaving and starting treatment upon return.

    The surgeon took a good look around when he had the camera in me, so my Oncologist is OK with this plan.
  • Scambuster
    Scambuster Member Posts: 973
    smokeyjoe said:

    Well, went out for nice
    Well, went out for nice dinner with lifelong friends tonight.....my girlfriend told me another close friend of hers was just diagnosed with colon cancer and she basically had the same surgery as me.....so, now my friend has booked herself for a colonoscopy :) With two people close to her having the same cancer got her thinking, good thing she's now getting herself checked.

    SmokeyJoe - Acid Vs Alkaline
    Hi Smokey,

    If you wish to do the Alkalizing things, best to do it with diet. The conflicts arise with the medics that Blood pH can't be altered an if it were, we would all die. Other parts of the body however do not get the pH regulated as rigorously as the blood, nor in the same manner, and most cancers occur in other parts of the body than the blood.

    You may wish to buy some litmus strips and test your Saliva and Urine. Mine all tested around high 5's to mid 6's in late 2009. Neutral pH is 7.0 Below that is Acidic and above is Alkaline.

    I'm not going to bother with the 'Does it work or not' here, you have make that your own decision. So, there are foods that 'Acidify' your body, and those that 'Alkalize' it. Some are very different to what you may expect i.e. Citrus is an acidic food, BUT it has an Alkalizing effect on your body. So eating Alkalizing foods in the right amount, and reducing the acidifying foods, will help you body get to an Alkaine state (over 7.0). THey say for disease free people, to eat 60/40% Alkalizing foods, while those with disease or wnating to fend off a recurrence (us), then go 75/25 -80/20.

    I have done the major diet change and my body is now slightly Alkaline. I feel great and all my previous ailments including :Headaches, Gout, Fibromyalgia (Joint and Muscle pain), and avcid reflux are all gone. After 30 years of suffering, that is a relief I can tell you.

    Best not to rely on a pill or powder to change you body pH. Use diet. Funnily enough, most of the Alkalizing foods are also on the same list as the 'Good' foods recommend in most Anti-Cancer diets (most fresh friuts and veges). Similarly, all the bad Acid producing foods are on the DO NOT EAT list of the same diet: Meats, Sugars, alcohol, processed foods. You can do a simple search and you will get websites with list of Acidizing foods and the alkalizing foods. Find one and print it off and stick it on your fridge(Here is just one of many: http://www.thewolfeclinic.com/acidalkfoods.html

    From all the studies i have done and am still doing, a common thread among long term survivors is that that changed their diet. These common changes are going mostly or all Vegetarian, get pof processed foods, sugars and fried foods, and consume fresh fruits, veges, pulses and whole grains. REgardless of what you believe, people who use this diet are generally, statistically and clinically healthier that those still on the SAD (Standard American Diet) as punted by the FDA.

    So if you want to do it, do it with diet, you have nothing to lose and everything to gain.

    Best regards
    Scambuster

    PS Not wishing to complicate things, but you may wish to do the same search and print for the 'Anti-Angiogeneis' Food list. These foods are shown to reduce the ability of the cancer cells to trigger the genesis of their own blood vessels which is critical for the advance of Cancer. Not a bad arrow to have in your quiver and funnily, many of the same foods appear.
  • HollyID
    HollyID Member Posts: 946 Member
    smokeyjoe said:

    Hey Lisa, at the risk of
    Hey Lisa, at the risk of sounding dumb, but you are into the holistic, juicing etc. Do you believe in drinking water with baking soda added to increase alkaline in your diet?? I've started looking into alternatives to help, and came across an article .... seems kinda simple!! Does this make any sense to you??

    Now, I could be wrong (and I
    Now, I could be wrong (and I usually am) but I don't think I'd do baking soda. I think it would elevate your sodium too much. I'd go with what Scouty did and put in lemon juice. It's a win-win situation. Kidneys love the citric acid and it won't up the sodium level in your body.