FYI:"The Dirty Dozen" and "The CleanFifteen"

Options
coloCan
coloCan Member Posts: 1,944 Member
edited June 2011 in Colorectal Cancer #1
According to the Environmental Working Group, the following twelve fruits and vegetables were most often contaminated with pesticides, starting with the most "dirty":
1. apples
2. celery
3. strawberries
4. peaches
5. spinach
6. nectarines (imported)
7. grapes (imported)
8. sweet bell peppers
9. potatoes
10. bananas##
11. lettuce
12. kale/collard greens

## =don;t know why I typed bananas,should be BLUEBERRIES,(Joe below is correct)


The "clean" fifteen were found to contain the lowesrt amount of pesticides, starting with:
1. onions, then
2. corn**
3. pineapples
4. avocadoes
5. asparagus
6. sweet peas
7. mangoes
8. eggplant
9. domestic cantaloupe
10. kiwi
11. cabbage
12. watermelon
13. sweet potato
14. grapefruit
15. mushrooms

**=won't bring up possibility that most US grown corn may already be GMed.....

Comments

  • Lovekitties
    Lovekitties Member Posts: 3,364 Member
    Options
    I read this article
    It stated that these foods were tested as normally eaten, i.e. washed and in some cases peeled. I was surprised to find that washed, peeled apples, bananas and potatoes were on the 'dirty' list.

    Here is more:

    The Shopper's Guide was developed by Environmental Working Group (EWG), based on the results of nearly 43,000 tests for pesticides on produce by the Department of Agriculture and the Food and Drug Administration between 2000 and 2004. EWG's computer analysis found that consumers could cut their pesticide exposure by almost 90 percent by avoiding the most contaminated fruits and vegetables and eating the least contaminated instead.

    Eating the 12 most contaminated fruits and vegetables will expose a person to about 15 pesticides a day, on average. Eating the 12 least contaminated will expose a person to fewer than two pesticides a day.

    "Federal produce tests tell us that some fruits and vegetables are so likely to be contaminated with pesticides that you should always buy them organic," said Richard Wiles, EWG's senior vice president. "Others are so consistently clean that you can eat them with less concern. With the Shopper's Guide in your pocket, it's easy to tell which is which."

    EWG's analysis of federal testing data found:
    •Peaches and apples topped the Dirty Dozen list. Almost 97 percent of peaches tested positive for pesticides, and almost 87 percent had two or more pesticide residues. About 92 percent of apples tested positive, and 79 percent had two or more pesticides. The rest of the Dirty Dozen include sweet bell peppers, celery, nectarines, strawberries, cherries, pears, imported grapes, spinach, lettuce, and potatoes.
    •Onions, avocados, and sweet corn headed the Consistently Clean list. For all three foods, more than 90 percent of the samples tested had no detectable pesticide residues. Others on the Consistently Clean list include pineapples, mango, asparagus, sweet peas, kiwi, bananas, cabbage, broccoli, and papaya.

    The above is from http://www.ewg.org/release/when-should-you-buy-organic

    Please note that this was based on information gathered between 2000 and 2004.

    My personal take is that I will be careful, as always, about food prep, but continue to eat those things which have other good things going for them.

    Marie
  • Joecham
    Joecham Member Posts: 13
    Options
    Bananas ?
    Hi colo I have a similar from the envirmental working group also, but bananas due to the thick skin should be in least contaminated. Usually the thick skinned fruit and veggies are ok, especially if you peel them.

    12 Most Contaminated
    Peaches
    Apples
    Sweet Bell Peppers
    Celery
    Nectarines
    Strawberries
    Cherries
    Pears
    Grapes (Imported)
    Spinach
    Lettuce
    Potatoes
     
    12 Least Contaminated
    Onions
    Avocado
    Sweet Corn (Frozen)
    Pineapples
    Mango
    Asparagus
    Sweet Peas (Frozen)
    Kiwi Fruit
    Bananas
    Cabbage
    Broccoli
    Papaya


    Let me know if that was just a typo because I could swear bannaas were ok. I won't get started on gmo corn either, lol

    Thanks
    Joseph.
  • coloCan
    coloCan Member Posts: 1,944 Member
    Options
    Joecham said:

    Bananas ?
    Hi colo I have a similar from the envirmental working group also, but bananas due to the thick skin should be in least contaminated. Usually the thick skinned fruit and veggies are ok, especially if you peel them.

    12 Most Contaminated
    Peaches
    Apples
    Sweet Bell Peppers
    Celery
    Nectarines
    Strawberries
    Cherries
    Pears
    Grapes (Imported)
    Spinach
    Lettuce
    Potatoes
     
    12 Least Contaminated
    Onions
    Avocado
    Sweet Corn (Frozen)
    Pineapples
    Mango
    Asparagus
    Sweet Peas (Frozen)
    Kiwi Fruit
    Bananas
    Cabbage
    Broccoli
    Papaya


    Let me know if that was just a typo because I could swear bannaas were ok. I won't get started on gmo corn either, lol

    Thanks
    Joseph.

    this stuff
    kinda grows on ya........



    (what else can you do with dupicates when you can't delete?)
  • coloCan
    coloCan Member Posts: 1,944 Member
    Options
    Joecham said:

    Bananas ?
    Hi colo I have a similar from the envirmental working group also, but bananas due to the thick skin should be in least contaminated. Usually the thick skinned fruit and veggies are ok, especially if you peel them.

    12 Most Contaminated
    Peaches
    Apples
    Sweet Bell Peppers
    Celery
    Nectarines
    Strawberries
    Cherries
    Pears
    Grapes (Imported)
    Spinach
    Lettuce
    Potatoes
     
    12 Least Contaminated
    Onions
    Avocado
    Sweet Corn (Frozen)
    Pineapples
    Mango
    Asparagus
    Sweet Peas (Frozen)
    Kiwi Fruit
    Bananas
    Cabbage
    Broccoli
    Papaya


    Let me know if that was just a typo because I could swear bannaas were ok. I won't get started on gmo corn either, lol

    Thanks
    Joseph.

    Got my info at the following:
    www.emaxhealth.com/1506/apple-knock-celery-top-dirty-dozen-produce-list

    it can still be found at emaxhealth.com

    if you search for "dirty dozen"


    and this is a prime example of chemobrain at work......Joe is absolutely correct--I fukked up--it should be BLUEBERRIES at #10, nor bananas......Damn!!!!!(Ineed a different proofreader than the typist)

    steve
  • Joecham
    Joecham Member Posts: 13
    Options
    coloCan said:

    Got my info at the following:
    www.emaxhealth.com/1506/apple-knock-celery-top-dirty-dozen-produce-list

    it can still be found at emaxhealth.com

    if you search for "dirty dozen"


    and this is a prime example of chemobrain at work......Joe is absolutely correct--I fukked up--it should be BLUEBERRIES at #10, nor bananas......Damn!!!!!(Ineed a different proofreader than the typist)

    steve

    Blueberries
    Hi steve

    Think you mixed up bananas with blueberries, I checked the link you sent and it was blueberries not bananas.

    Phew thought I was going crazy for a second

    Thanks for posting great post by the way always have my dirty dozen list available as to save money at whole foods. I only buy what I have to because whole foods rapes your wallet,lol.
    Thanks again
    Joseph
  • plh4gail
    plh4gail Member Posts: 1,238 Member
    Options
    Joecham said:

    Bananas ?
    Hi colo I have a similar from the envirmental working group also, but bananas due to the thick skin should be in least contaminated. Usually the thick skinned fruit and veggies are ok, especially if you peel them.

    12 Most Contaminated
    Peaches
    Apples
    Sweet Bell Peppers
    Celery
    Nectarines
    Strawberries
    Cherries
    Pears
    Grapes (Imported)
    Spinach
    Lettuce
    Potatoes
     
    12 Least Contaminated
    Onions
    Avocado
    Sweet Corn (Frozen)
    Pineapples
    Mango
    Asparagus
    Sweet Peas (Frozen)
    Kiwi Fruit
    Bananas
    Cabbage
    Broccoli
    Papaya


    Let me know if that was just a typo because I could swear bannaas were ok. I won't get started on gmo corn either, lol

    Thanks
    Joseph.

    So how do you get the
    So how do you get the produce listed on the dirty dozen so you (I) can eat them? Without all the yucky pesticides. Is the organic the way you do that?

    Not meaning to sound dingy, it's just that...well...when it comes to the combination of recently had chemo and just learning about healthier stuff which I want to do....I guess I'm dingy.
  • pete43lost_at_sea
    pete43lost_at_sea Member Posts: 3,900 Member
    Options
    not sure how closely this matches our aussie produce. but its a good starting point.

    thanks for posting this steve.

    i am more grateful for the 3 month supply of home grown mandarins from my fatherin laws fruit trees. pesticde free.

    also more harmful dioxins in meat, so plant based is the way for me, also given the low level of pesticide its not been proven to cause cancer. obviously minimising pesticide exposure is prudent.

    based on my research i would think a steak or bic mac far more harmful to my health then a leafy green salad. washed of course.

    hugs,
    pete
  • Joecham
    Joecham Member Posts: 13
    Options
    plh4gail said:

    So how do you get the
    So how do you get the produce listed on the dirty dozen so you (I) can eat them? Without all the yucky pesticides. Is the organic the way you do that?

    Not meaning to sound dingy, it's just that...well...when it comes to the combination of recently had chemo and just learning about healthier stuff which I want to do....I guess I'm dingy.

    Hi gail
    Hi Gail

    I just buy organic or I grow my own organic food in my back yard depending on the season. However you can by non organic fruits and vegi that are on the leas contaminated. Usually the thicker the skin the safer it is if it is non organic, everything else you should eat organic to avoid polluting you body with any more toxins. If you learn to sprout, sprouts are 30 time more nutritious than the best organic vegetables and you can do it from your home. I will eventually post a you tube video on how to do it. It can be done inside your home for pennys. Juice them and eat them in salads and you are ensuring huge amount of nutrition.
    Joseph
  • scouty
    scouty Member Posts: 1,965 Member
    Options
    plh4gail said:

    So how do you get the
    So how do you get the produce listed on the dirty dozen so you (I) can eat them? Without all the yucky pesticides. Is the organic the way you do that?

    Not meaning to sound dingy, it's just that...well...when it comes to the combination of recently had chemo and just learning about healthier stuff which I want to do....I guess I'm dingy.

    2 ways
    Gail,

    You can go the organic route or you can shop at one of the health food supermarkets like Whole Foods, Earthfare, Wild Oats, Trader Joes or local co-ops where they guarantee fruits and veggies that are not exposed to pesticides. Organic takes work and years to get all the bad stuff out of the soil. What you will see will be signs saying conventional or organic. Conventional is okay with the dirty dozen at the health food stores.

    FYI, recent testing is showing organic foods to have more nutrients too! Much like grass fed beef having more protein and less fat then grain fed beef.

    Also, locally grown "stuff" from curb markets or farmers markets beats store bought organic due to the freshest "stuff" having the most nutrients. Better yet, learn how to grow your own. Over the years I have added blueberries, raspberries, and blackberries to my yard and they are very easy to maintain. I also have a big garden with the usuals. I love it and have learned so much the last 5-6 years! Just picked my summers garlic yesterday (12 heads).

    Ask away, it is the best way to learn. We were all new at this at one time too!!!

    Lisa P.