CSN Login
Members Online: 21

Why keep the kidney?

Posts: 1
Joined: Jul 2005

Hello everyone. Hoping to get some information/opinions.

When a malignant tumor is found on the kidney (stage 1, no matistiss), why wouldn't you want to completely remove the kidney if you have another healthy one? Is there a benefit to keeping a portion of it? My thought is to "get that thing out ~ we don't want the cancer coming back!"

Why is the surgeon pushing for a partial removal and to "save" as much of the kidney as possible?

Thanks so much!

Chicago's picture
Posts: 74
Joined: Apr 2004

Basically, because two kidneys are better than one.

I have been told by my docs that, in a worst case scenario, you could still function and survive on as much as one third of one healthy kidney. So if all or most of one kidney was compromised by a tumor, they will usually take the whole thing out.

But your situation does not sound like the whole kidney has been compromised. They can usually see (prior to surgery) whether a Stage 1 tumor has spread within the kidney.

As I understand it, there is no greater risk of the cancer coming back in the affected kidney than there would be in the other one. And if you take one whole kidney out now, but the cancer reappears in the other kidney later, you're screwed.

It is usually a good rule of thumb to keep as much as you can. People lose kidneys every day to physical injuries. It would always be good to have a backup.

We only found my cancer in one kidney because I developed kidney stones in the other. Kidney stones are usually not serious in one kidney (just incredibly painful), because you have another one to keep working. Kidney stones could become very serious though, if you only have the one kidney.

I had the same diagnosis as you, and I am very happy today to still have (nearly) two functioning kidneys.

Posts: 1
Joined: Feb 2008

I had a right radical nephrectomy about 6 weeks ago and am now having sharp pains in the area of my remaining left kidney when I move around. I have no pain when I sit still. You had kidney stones,what were your symptoms? You mentioned more potential problems with kidney stones if you have one kidney. Can you elaborate. Thanks

Posts: 1564
Joined: May 2006

No snake ever survived to tell you his oil was good. did you ever work for free and make a good product ? I's a billion times cheaper than what the medical profession charges and the pharmacies with their toxic poisons? would you go to a professional who's sucess rate was less than 75 % that the discription of most of the oncologists in the world.

You need to go to a "annatech site"and actually kick the tires on it and put on the speedometer about 700,000 miles before saying you want to die and order your plot "Try it It works" I am an 8 time cancer survivor My e-mail and site are listed: I dare you to prove me incorrect on anything I have stated here today. information is available . "ONE ARE AS BLIND AS THOSE WHO WILL NOT SEE"

Home Products Opportunity Company Associate Directory Mannatech Community
Products Order Form FAQs
Contact Information Mannatech Incorporated
600 S. Royal Lane, Suite 200
Coppell, TX 75019
(main number)
(972) 471-7400

Customer Service Department
(direct line)
(m-f 9:00 am-7:30 pm cst)
(972) 471-8111
(972) 471-8120 in Spanish
(972) 471-8112 in French
for the hearing impaired:
(972) 471-8119 TTY
Interactive Voice Response (IVR):
(972) 471-1550
Customer Service Fax Line
(800) 825-6584 Main
(972) 471-8117 Canadian

Webmaster Email

Share The Gift Call
Recruiting Calls
(877) manna4me or
(877) 626-6246
Every Monday and Thursday
at 8:00 p.m. CT

Mannatech Online Documents
(972) 660-1990
(972) 471-7462 Preview Pack

Information Line
(24 hrs/day, 7 days/week)
(888) 346-INFO or
(888) 346-4636
Leadership Connection Team
(2-Star National or above)
(972) 471-8190 info.
(972) 471-8191 fax

Member Product Order

Associate Product Order
by Credit Card or Checks by Phone
(m-f 7:00 am-12:00 midnight cst & sat. 8:30 am-5:30 pm cst)
(800) 281-4469
(800) 481-2444 Retail
(800) 267-2722 Fax
(800) 472-0149 In Spanish
(800) 472-1186 In French
for the Hearing Impaired:
(800) 779-0897 TTY

Mannatech Promotional Materials (MPM)
(800) 281-4469

Special Events Line
(888) 9 EVENTS or
(888) 938-3687

Training Line
(972) 471-7480

(800) 364-9700

Contact Us | Site Guide | Terms/Privacy
Mannatech Project Identifier: 5304 Last Modified: Monday, July 18, 2005

Subscribe with RSS
About Cancer Society

The content on this site is for informational purposes only. It is not a substitute for professional medical advice. Do not use this information to diagnose or treat a health problem or disease without consulting with a qualified healthcare provider. Please consult your healthcare provider with any questions or concerns you may have regarding your condition. Use of this online service is subject to the disclaimer and the terms and conditions.

Copyright 2000-2014 © Cancer Survivors Network