Are you happy with your breast 's appearance after the lumpectomy?

2Floridiansisters
2Floridiansisters Member Posts: 384 Member
edited March 2014 in Breast Cancer #1
Here I am still uncertain of what to do, I met the radiation doctor today, he says I'll do fine if I have the lumpectomy, but what he isn't realizing is I have Invasive Lobular Carcinoma, and it has a tendencey to show up in the opposite breast. I don't want to ever do this again. I have DD boobs so I can easily afford to let go of some tissue but I was kind of thinking I would really enjoy size B boobs, ****, what do I do? I have to give my answer to my surgeon tomorrow, he said he would respect whatever choice I make.

Comments

  • ms.sunshine
    ms.sunshine Member Posts: 707 Member
    I struggled with the same decision
    I know the stress your under. No one can and will tell you what to do this decision is ALL yours. The day I saw my surgeon I still hadn't decided. I said God you better do something I'm down to the wire. I decided then I for some reason whole heartedly trust this dr. I ask him what he thought. He told me, he ask me if I was having a hard time deciding told me it was fear and ask me to talk to him about it. When I did the answer came.

    I had a lumpectomy. Isn't perfect, but not to bad. I think it depends on how much he has to remove. He removed some tissue from my right breast also just to even me up. It sure did make a difference since then I haven't suffered with back aches. I wish he would have removed more. Afterwards you can still see a plastic surgeon. I'm going to give myself a break, then talk to a PS I would like to get a lift, and maybe a little more taken out.

    My doc said you didn't get cancer because you have breast. Your body made cancer, and it settled in the breast. There's no guarantee that it will or won't come back. If your body makes cancer it has to go somewhere. That's why people have recurrences. No one wants to go thru the treatments again, but if the cancer comes back with breasts more than likely it will return to the breast and we can deal with it again. If no breast it will go elsewhere. Of course there is no guarantees when dealing with cancer.

    Talk to your surgeon be bold and ask questions. Let us know what decision you made, and be at peace. Take care.
    Jennifer
  • jk1952
    jk1952 Member Posts: 613

    I struggled with the same decision
    I know the stress your under. No one can and will tell you what to do this decision is ALL yours. The day I saw my surgeon I still hadn't decided. I said God you better do something I'm down to the wire. I decided then I for some reason whole heartedly trust this dr. I ask him what he thought. He told me, he ask me if I was having a hard time deciding told me it was fear and ask me to talk to him about it. When I did the answer came.

    I had a lumpectomy. Isn't perfect, but not to bad. I think it depends on how much he has to remove. He removed some tissue from my right breast also just to even me up. It sure did make a difference since then I haven't suffered with back aches. I wish he would have removed more. Afterwards you can still see a plastic surgeon. I'm going to give myself a break, then talk to a PS I would like to get a lift, and maybe a little more taken out.

    My doc said you didn't get cancer because you have breast. Your body made cancer, and it settled in the breast. There's no guarantee that it will or won't come back. If your body makes cancer it has to go somewhere. That's why people have recurrences. No one wants to go thru the treatments again, but if the cancer comes back with breasts more than likely it will return to the breast and we can deal with it again. If no breast it will go elsewhere. Of course there is no guarantees when dealing with cancer.

    Talk to your surgeon be bold and ask questions. Let us know what decision you made, and be at peace. Take care.
    Jennifer

    Ronda, I think that the

    Ronda, I think that the advice to talk to your doctor about this is good. I have always put a lot of faith in my breast surgeon because I trust her and she has a lot of experience dealing with breast cancer. Her advice has always been excellent and well-thought-out.

    I had invasive lobular cancer also, and it never recurred in that breast or the other one. I wouldn't base my decision on that alone.

    As far as the lumpectomy, it does matter how much you have to have removed. I had small breasts and I didn't really notice much difference between the two after my lumpectomy.

    Joyce
  • 2Floridiansisters
    2Floridiansisters Member Posts: 384 Member
    I swear this whole cancer mess is driving me nuts.....
    One day I'm all for the double mastectomy and now I'm being told "start out small and go from there, why do something so drastic if you don't realy have to". uuuggghhhhhh

    I was hoping to get out of doing radiation, I have no idea why but it just sounds so scary to me. And he told me he would stsrt me out with 33 treatments, and he said the double mastectomy with tissue expanders would be a long drawn out process. uuuugggghhhh

    Why do we have to do anything........he said think of my breast as a muffin, I can go in there and pick at it little by little until it's all gone but there would be crumbs sitting there when I was done, he said those crumbs are like the cancer cells that an MRI can't detect, that's why we have to move forward no matter how scared we feel. uuuggghhhh

    Hck yes I'm scared but I just want to do the process that's the lesser of two evils as far as reovery. The radiation sounds horrible.


    I'm going crazy,
  • missrenee
    missrenee Member Posts: 2,136 Member

    I swear this whole cancer mess is driving me nuts.....
    One day I'm all for the double mastectomy and now I'm being told "start out small and go from there, why do something so drastic if you don't realy have to". uuuggghhhhhh

    I was hoping to get out of doing radiation, I have no idea why but it just sounds so scary to me. And he told me he would stsrt me out with 33 treatments, and he said the double mastectomy with tissue expanders would be a long drawn out process. uuuugggghhhh

    Why do we have to do anything........he said think of my breast as a muffin, I can go in there and pick at it little by little until it's all gone but there would be crumbs sitting there when I was done, he said those crumbs are like the cancer cells that an MRI can't detect, that's why we have to move forward no matter how scared we feel. uuuggghhhh

    Hck yes I'm scared but I just want to do the process that's the lesser of two evils as far as reovery. The radiation sounds horrible.


    I'm going crazy,

    I had a lumpectomy,
    chemo and am on treatment #27 (out of 35) of radiation today. The radiation is not horrible. I've actually just started to get a little red and sore, but other than some fatigue, it's been going very well. My breast looks pretty darn good for having had a lumpectomy and a revision of the lumpectomy 10 days later for unclear margins. You have to be comfortable with your choice, though. I listened to my experts and followed their advice.

    Good luck and try to think positive, stay calm, and be confident in your choice.

    Hugs, Renee
  • Jean 0609
    Jean 0609 Member Posts: 2,462
    I know what you are going through
    I originally had a lumpectomy and no my boob (DD) was not disfigured. Actually, it didn't look bad at all. Like I stated before, my margins weren't clear, and that is when I opted for the mastectomy (left breast with reduction of right breast). The mastectomy was my decision. I'm the one that had to live with it and others can give you advice, however, in the end...it's all up to you. Hang in there. You will be fine, whichever road you choose and remember we are all here for you. Big hugs, Jean
  • Betsy13
    Betsy13 Member Posts: 185
    small busted
    I am very small busted. After my lumpectomy, I now enjoy a divet in my breast. My rad. onc. told me my breast will continually change for approx. 1 year. I am waiting until Christmas to make a decision if I want to do anything. I've already decided that if this crap ever comes back, I will be having a double mastectomy with reconstructions. I'm with you, I don't ever want to do this again, either. I wish you well with whatever you choose.
  • webbwife50
    webbwife50 Member Posts: 394
    HI
    I have worn your shoes girl! I'm 51 and June 09, was diagnosed with an agressive mature tumor in my right breast. It was triple negative so chemo was it. Lumpectomy was an option but I too had DD boobies, and was terrified I would go through all the treatments and then it would return in the other breast. I opted for biloateral mastectomy. It has been quite a year!! But I'm am on the mend now. I have two nice barbie boobs, quite small, close to a B cup. When I am ready my doc is going to even up the few inperfection and start the nipples. The truth is I'm really very happy with the results of my tram flap reconstruction. I had a fabulous plastic sugeon, with the highest recommendatios. I didn't have to do radiation. Nor do I have to wear a bra, or get mamograms, or worry much about whats on my chest. If you'd like to talk you can e-mail me at webbwife50@yahoo.com . I know for myself I knew deep down what treatment plan was best for me based on all, not just one, of the professionals who advised me. God Bless You!
    Alison
  • aisling8
    aisling8 Member Posts: 1,627 Member

    HI
    I have worn your shoes girl! I'm 51 and June 09, was diagnosed with an agressive mature tumor in my right breast. It was triple negative so chemo was it. Lumpectomy was an option but I too had DD boobies, and was terrified I would go through all the treatments and then it would return in the other breast. I opted for biloateral mastectomy. It has been quite a year!! But I'm am on the mend now. I have two nice barbie boobs, quite small, close to a B cup. When I am ready my doc is going to even up the few inperfection and start the nipples. The truth is I'm really very happy with the results of my tram flap reconstruction. I had a fabulous plastic sugeon, with the highest recommendatios. I didn't have to do radiation. Nor do I have to wear a bra, or get mamograms, or worry much about whats on my chest. If you'd like to talk you can e-mail me at webbwife50@yahoo.com . I know for myself I knew deep down what treatment plan was best for me based on all, not just one, of the professionals who advised me. God Bless You!
    Alison

    Waiting and deciding
    those are two such hard things.

    My tumor was very small and every doctor I saw told me I was an excellent candidate for a lumpectomy and rads which is what I chose. I'm small busted so I was somewhat concerned what I'd end up looking like. It's all fine. The affected side is perky and the left-alone side looks like what you'd imagine a 58 year old breast would look like!! It just makes me laugh. Rads were not a problem -- a little tired, but I also went into it without chemo so I'm sure I had way more energy than someone beginning after having had chemo.

    I wish you peace.

    xo,
    Victoria
  • jo jo
    jo jo Member Posts: 1,175
    I had the lumpectomy then
    I had the lumpectomy then got a mastectomy and it was a good thing i did cuz they discovered my cancer had spread more than they thought...So in my case im sooo thankful i did get the mastectomy or id be doing this all over again.
    Good luck in your decision, i know its going to be a hard one to make.
    Keep us posted on what you decide.
  • Skeezie
    Skeezie Member Posts: 586 Member
    jo jo said:

    I had the lumpectomy then
    I had the lumpectomy then got a mastectomy and it was a good thing i did cuz they discovered my cancer had spread more than they thought...So in my case im sooo thankful i did get the mastectomy or id be doing this all over again.
    Good luck in your decision, i know its going to be a hard one to make.
    Keep us posted on what you decide.

    I have/had D boobs/boob.
    I had a lumpectomy and then a re-excisional lumpectomy. the second one he took a ton of tissue. It was a little noticeable but I would have been happy with it. One margin still wasn't clear so I opted for a single, simple mastectomy. I am triple neg. I was terrified of chemo, but once you get started on the journey it all falls into place. I didn't have to have rads because when there were no cancel cells found in the breast tissue and I was really happy about that.

    So until you really get into the surgery/treatment part it's still all a guess...you won't know til it starts happening. I am happy to still have my one breast, I wish I could have stayed with a lumpectomy, but it's all turned out ok. I am a wimp and did not want any more surgery than I had to have. I really admire all the ladies who go thru all the reconstruction. But I am happy with what I have.

    It's a horrible decision to make, you already have great advice in talking with your surgeon to help you.

    I am anxious to hear what yhou decide, I know this has been a really tough battle for you these past few weeks...but it actually does get better once you get into treatment. No guess work, the battle begins and it's full speed ahead.

    Hugs, Judy :-)
  • m_azingrace
    m_azingrace Member Posts: 399
    Skeezie said:

    I have/had D boobs/boob.
    I had a lumpectomy and then a re-excisional lumpectomy. the second one he took a ton of tissue. It was a little noticeable but I would have been happy with it. One margin still wasn't clear so I opted for a single, simple mastectomy. I am triple neg. I was terrified of chemo, but once you get started on the journey it all falls into place. I didn't have to have rads because when there were no cancel cells found in the breast tissue and I was really happy about that.

    So until you really get into the surgery/treatment part it's still all a guess...you won't know til it starts happening. I am happy to still have my one breast, I wish I could have stayed with a lumpectomy, but it's all turned out ok. I am a wimp and did not want any more surgery than I had to have. I really admire all the ladies who go thru all the reconstruction. But I am happy with what I have.

    It's a horrible decision to make, you already have great advice in talking with your surgeon to help you.

    I am anxious to hear what yhou decide, I know this has been a really tough battle for you these past few weeks...but it actually does get better once you get into treatment. No guess work, the battle begins and it's full speed ahead.

    Hugs, Judy :-)

    One hung low
    I had a lumpectomy last July, and now my girls are no longer twins. The lumpectomy one is a little higher and firmer than her lazy sister, but she also looks a little mashed in. It's not noticeable when I'm fully dressed. I felt very deformed until I went for a mammogram the first week of July, and the technician asked which one had the lumpectomy. After I told her, she said that it was one of the best lumpectomies she's seen in the 20-something years she'd been doing mammograms. I do think that in the past year, it has filled in quite a bit, but they still don't match. However, the results of the mammogram were good, so I'm not complaining at all! Hugs to you all. Gracie
  • VickiSam
    VickiSam Member Posts: 9,079 Member

    One hung low
    I had a lumpectomy last July, and now my girls are no longer twins. The lumpectomy one is a little higher and firmer than her lazy sister, but she also looks a little mashed in. It's not noticeable when I'm fully dressed. I felt very deformed until I went for a mammogram the first week of July, and the technician asked which one had the lumpectomy. After I told her, she said that it was one of the best lumpectomies she's seen in the 20-something years she'd been doing mammograms. I do think that in the past year, it has filled in quite a bit, but they still don't match. However, the results of the mammogram were good, so I'm not complaining at all! Hugs to you all. Gracie

    Yes .. I was concaved slightly .. and deformed after
    my lumpectomy. My tumor was the size of an Orange. I was a solid C cup, so it was obvious! I opted for a bi-lateral Mact'my - so now I am going thru reconstruction .. and find myself looking at my new boobies, a few times a day .. with and without clothing.

    We all beat to a different drummer, if my breast cancer has not been so invasive along with hi grade, and her2 positive - I would of just keep my breast and lived concaved.


    Vicki Sam
  • summerautumn
    summerautumn Member Posts: 2
    been there
    I had breast cancer at 33 and they told me a lumpectomy would work fine with 8 weeks of radiation. That was the oncologist recommendations in the 90. I was tired with radiation but I went to work almost everyday and was the last patient of the day at the clinic.

    It has been 12 years I am now 46 and I have breast cancer again, same breast different kind of cancer this only happens in 3% or less of patients. We'll we now have to ask ourselves I don't want to be worrying about it showing up in the other one in the next couple of years.

    I decided to had a double masectomy in March with tram flam skin from under your shoulder blades pulled around front to conform breast then they put expanders inside, then add saline till you get to the size you want I was a 40DD and I think I will go a little smaller this time. Once your saline is where you want it to be they put the implants in.
    Note all of these procedures take months some up to 18 months to complete I am in for the long all.
    Listen very carefully. The breast I had radiation on in 97 was really bad burnt tissue and the plastic doctor said everything would be great. When they pulled the flap from the back and attached it to a small portion of my original breast after about a week that
    area was not circulating and I had to have a surgery to remove the dead tissue and then he had to pull what skin he was working with together. Two weeks later it started to come apart. We had to take a skin graph off of my leg to put on my breast to have more good skin. So after all of this I would say if you have a high change to get it in the other breast do the masectomy and reconstruction if you want nice breast again. Once that skin is radiated you can't really use it for anything good later on.
    Hope this help and doesn't scare you. Listen to what they say but ask questions and if you need to get more than one opionin then do so we did. And we went with the second doctor and we are really happy. I am taking chemo now that most of my masectomy has healed and the drains are gone I take number 4 chemo tomorrow, I can never sleep the night before. Prayers to you and you will make the right choice but it has to be yours*
  • Angie2U
    Angie2U Member Posts: 2,991
    Jean 0609 said:

    I know what you are going through
    I originally had a lumpectomy and no my boob (DD) was not disfigured. Actually, it didn't look bad at all. Like I stated before, my margins weren't clear, and that is when I opted for the mastectomy (left breast with reduction of right breast). The mastectomy was my decision. I'm the one that had to live with it and others can give you advice, however, in the end...it's all up to you. Hang in there. You will be fine, whichever road you choose and remember we are all here for you. Big hugs, Jean

    I had a lumpectomy and am
    I had a lumpectomy and am very grateful that I did. You can hardly see the incision it is so small anymore and has healed so well. I don't know if anyone would know if they didn't know I had one quite honestly. My boob looks the same. Good luck!
  • susie09
    susie09 Member Posts: 2,930
    jo jo said:

    I had the lumpectomy then
    I had the lumpectomy then got a mastectomy and it was a good thing i did cuz they discovered my cancer had spread more than they thought...So in my case im sooo thankful i did get the mastectomy or id be doing this all over again.
    Good luck in your decision, i know its going to be a hard one to make.
    Keep us posted on what you decide.

    I had rads after my
    I had rads after my lumpectomy. I was so happy that I could have a lumpectomy and not have to have a mastectomy. I just don't know if I could have handled that. My breasts are important to me and I couldn't bear to even think of losing them. I am very happy with the outcome. My plastic surgeon did a great job!!

    Decide on what is the best thing for you to do.


    Good luck!
  • Double Whammy
    Double Whammy Member Posts: 2,832 Member

    been there
    I had breast cancer at 33 and they told me a lumpectomy would work fine with 8 weeks of radiation. That was the oncologist recommendations in the 90. I was tired with radiation but I went to work almost everyday and was the last patient of the day at the clinic.

    It has been 12 years I am now 46 and I have breast cancer again, same breast different kind of cancer this only happens in 3% or less of patients. We'll we now have to ask ourselves I don't want to be worrying about it showing up in the other one in the next couple of years.

    I decided to had a double masectomy in March with tram flam skin from under your shoulder blades pulled around front to conform breast then they put expanders inside, then add saline till you get to the size you want I was a 40DD and I think I will go a little smaller this time. Once your saline is where you want it to be they put the implants in.
    Note all of these procedures take months some up to 18 months to complete I am in for the long all.
    Listen very carefully. The breast I had radiation on in 97 was really bad burnt tissue and the plastic doctor said everything would be great. When they pulled the flap from the back and attached it to a small portion of my original breast after about a week that
    area was not circulating and I had to have a surgery to remove the dead tissue and then he had to pull what skin he was working with together. Two weeks later it started to come apart. We had to take a skin graph off of my leg to put on my breast to have more good skin. So after all of this I would say if you have a high change to get it in the other breast do the masectomy and reconstruction if you want nice breast again. Once that skin is radiated you can't really use it for anything good later on.
    Hope this help and doesn't scare you. Listen to what they say but ask questions and if you need to get more than one opionin then do so we did. And we went with the second doctor and we are really happy. I am taking chemo now that most of my masectomy has healed and the drains are gone I take number 4 chemo tomorrow, I can never sleep the night before. Prayers to you and you will make the right choice but it has to be yours*

    I'm even now
    My bc was in my right breast, which has always been considerably larger than the left. They are now closer to a matched set than they ever have been. People say they never noticed, but I did - my shirts plackets were never straight, tops pulled to the right, necklaces hung more to the right, my cleavage as fuller on the right, etc., etc., etc. I was very self conscious of it. The breast surgeon did a pretty good job of moving tissue around and I am absolutely pleased with the results.

    Suzanne
  • Kylez
    Kylez Member Posts: 3,761 Member
    missrenee said:

    I had a lumpectomy,
    chemo and am on treatment #27 (out of 35) of radiation today. The radiation is not horrible. I've actually just started to get a little red and sore, but other than some fatigue, it's been going very well. My breast looks pretty darn good for having had a lumpectomy and a revision of the lumpectomy 10 days later for unclear margins. You have to be comfortable with your choice, though. I listened to my experts and followed their advice.

    Good luck and try to think positive, stay calm, and be confident in your choice.

    Hugs, Renee

    The final word is yours and
    The final word is yours and that is what matters. Ofcourse, take what your doctor's advise for you to do.

    I am very happy that I could have a lumpectomy with rads! My breast looks great!
  • KayNYC
    KayNYC Member Posts: 495 Member
    decisions
    Of course we have to make decisions that we feel are right for us, we are the ones that will have to live with them. Since being diagnosed with BC it has been one decsion after another.
    My mass was very small and a lumpectomy with excision of nodes (6)was recommended. I am very happy with the appearance of the lumpectomy. both the underarm and breast scars are small, flat and fading. They kind of look like sidewise smiles. My D sized breasts were not of equal size before and now they are more similar. My husband says it looks great. The radiation was not bad. I had some redness and itching (below in the crease) however it was easily managed with hydrocortizone cream. The tan color has returned to normal. The hardest part of the whole thing has been the lymphedema that started after the surgery and before the radiation. I am completing my last session of OT/PT this week and will be discharged. My arm is now either smaller than my none effected arm in the lower arm and just .4cm larger at the top of my arm. Overall, affected arm is smaller in size than it was when I started treatment several weeks ago. The compression sleeve and glove as well as, the nightly manual lymphatic massage/drainage has been very effective. I purchased several sleeves in different colors and have made it a fashion accessory. Really can't complain...not in pain and I am active and working full time.
    Good luck with your decision. You will make the one that is best for you.
    Hugs, K