I have just read "being fat promotes angiogenesis" and mushrooms, greens, onions, berries help fight

pete43lost_at_sea
pete43lost_at_sea Member Posts: 3,900 Member
edited November 2011 in Colorectal Cancer #1
I am satisfied that my healthy diet now vegan is based on science and sound arguments.
just sharing these below, in case other crc are interested in this area.

I am reading super immunity by joel fuhrman.

anyone else got this, probably unlikely its hot off the presses, so the research is current as of printing.

this book advocates a vegan diet based on science to fight cancer, so stop reading if thats an issue for you. keep on reading if this if your interested. i am not going to respond to negative arguments , it just takes too much time and energy.

paraphassing page 73
fat secretes angiogenesis-promoting compounds, its a complex process that i won't retype.
their are lots of anti-angiogenic foods.

most of these are on my diet. mushrooms are top of the list.

i was told to really loose weight by naturopath 11 months ago.
well i am down to 90Kg from 137kg just before dx. thats 47 kg or over 100 pounds.
still got 7 kgs to go.

as i understand it, getting fatter encourages angiogenesis around the area where fat is being deposited.

the science and arguments in the pages 73 to 75 basically tie exercise therapy and diet together.

being thin is unfriendly to cancer is the main point i am trying to stress.

if you eat any cancer fighting foods, this book takes this to a whole other level.
i cannot put it down

hugs,
pete

ps this is a real interesting talk, its not just this book, checkout the angiogenesis foundation, this is a ted conference, so i hope its considered reputable.
http://www.wired.com/epicenter/2010/02/blood-vessels-key-to-cancer/

http://www.angio.org/
«1

Comments

  • Buckwirth
    Buckwirth Member Posts: 1,258 Member
  • yoga
    yoga Member Posts: 87
    new info always welcomed by me
    Thanks for the information Pete. I am always interested in reading new things - agree or not. I do wonder about the whole thin thing . . . . I have always been very slim (it is in the genes!) . . . . didn't help me much. I do eat lots of greens, onions and berries so guess I am doing something right. As for mushrooms, I have been really trying to go down that path, but it is a slow one for me. I have thought aboug going vegetarian, but I am allergic to all nuts and soy and most shellfish/fish, so I don't think I could do it. That said, I do ensure that I eat mostly fruits and veggies with only organic chicken, salmon and some low fat organic dairy.
    Keep posting new ideas - you never know when something is going to be a good fit for somebody.
    yoga jo
  • Annabelle41415
    Annabelle41415 Member Posts: 6,742 Member
    Ummmmm
    I've been thin all my life and always ate mushrooms, onions salads, tomatoes everyday and still got cancer. Sometimes I've got a really hard time believing in what people claim but if it works for you or them then I say go for it.

    Kim
  • laurettas
    laurettas Member Posts: 372

    Ummmmm
    I've been thin all my life and always ate mushrooms, onions salads, tomatoes everyday and still got cancer. Sometimes I've got a really hard time believing in what people claim but if it works for you or them then I say go for it.

    Kim

    Thank you, Kim
    Sometimes I worry that all the emphasis on diet and exercise can bring guilt on those who didn't eat and exercise "perfectly". So it is good to hear from people like you that did do all of the "healthy" things and got cancer anyway. Not that I am glad that you got cancer!! But for me it is a sign that we don't have the answers yet and need to keep looking for the actual causes and treatment of cancer. Also, I worry that this emphasis will cause more people to, like Steve Jobs, reject conventional methods of treatments for the alternatives to the detriment of their health. So, again, thank you for speaking up(And I don't mean "speaking up" like my granddaughter did, who when instructed to do so, lifted up her face and spoke in the same tone!!)
  • John23
    John23 Member Posts: 2,122 Member
    Buckwirth said:
    Humph

    So when I post information regarding the "fact" that nothing has
    improved with cancer therapy for the past 40 years, and I
    reference the data from a "blog"..... That's considered inferior
    data. But when it's posted in favor of the cancer industry,
    and the references come from a "blog", that's real data.

    Life's funny, ain't it?

    My best to youse all.

    John
  • Annabelle41415
    Annabelle41415 Member Posts: 6,742 Member
    laurettas said:

    Thank you, Kim
    Sometimes I worry that all the emphasis on diet and exercise can bring guilt on those who didn't eat and exercise "perfectly". So it is good to hear from people like you that did do all of the "healthy" things and got cancer anyway. Not that I am glad that you got cancer!! But for me it is a sign that we don't have the answers yet and need to keep looking for the actual causes and treatment of cancer. Also, I worry that this emphasis will cause more people to, like Steve Jobs, reject conventional methods of treatments for the alternatives to the detriment of their health. So, again, thank you for speaking up(And I don't mean "speaking up" like my granddaughter did, who when instructed to do so, lifted up her face and spoke in the same tone!!)

    You are Welcome
    Yea I've never been one for large quantity of red meats, never fried foods, always well balance meals so if someone claims it works for them I'm glad, but I'll still continue to exercise because that does make me feel better and love to walk. I've always been a veggie person though - just would pick a salad over desert but that's just me :)

    Kim
  • John23
    John23 Member Posts: 2,122 Member

    Ummmmm
    I've been thin all my life and always ate mushrooms, onions salads, tomatoes everyday and still got cancer. Sometimes I've got a really hard time believing in what people claim but if it works for you or them then I say go for it.

    Kim

    Kim -
    Kim -

    Re:
    "I've been thin all my life and always ate mushrooms, onions
    salads, tomatoes everyday and still got cancer. "


    We should keep in mind, that all store-bought veggies and fruits,
    and of course all meats... are treated at the farm and during
    processing for sale. Eating all that was once said to be good
    for us, may very well now, be killing us.

    Pesticides remain in the ground, and each crop multiplies the
    amount that remains. Mixtures of pesticides for each different
    crop, along with chemicals to enhance growing, all add to the
    unknown variable of toxins; how can anyone know what the
    interactions will result in, when no records of chemicals used
    have been recorded.

    And now nearly all countries are irradiating the food products,
    with many of the countries having no legal restriction to hold
    to specific limits of radiation used. That also adds to the
    carcinogenic effect of our food products.

    It may not be "just one peach", but the cumulative effect of all
    the processing of everything we eat, veggies, fruits, meat, fish....

    But.... there are depictions of humans with tumors, on cave walls....

    Stay well, Kim!
    (John)

    To others (you know who you are):

    It bothers me that there are some here that fear not doing chemo
    so much, that they denounce anything and anyone, that suggests
    that there is something better and safer than chemo and radiation.

    They seem to feel that they must scream from the rooftops,
    that anyone trying anything other than chemo and radiation
    is placing their life in extreme peril !

    And as a user of other than chemo/radiation, I find myself
    looking for that door that the others like me have walked
    out through...

    The others got tired of fighting the industry's brain washed,
    and gave up.

    I sincerely hate to "give up". I hate watching people die; of reading
    the sad news, month after month after month...

    I hate the thought of not telling about another way that works,
    especially when the so-called "proven way" is failing them,
    and they have no place but hospice to go.

    I'm only human, just as the others like me are. I'm tired of arguing
    against the industry, and against all those that believe so
    much in the industry's answer to cancer.

    It's almost six years for me... my "luck" isn't going to last forever...

    Golly gee. I sure wish I did chemo instead of those stupid herbs.

    </sarcasm>

    Happy, cheerful, and healthy thoughts to all!

    John
  • Annabelle41415
    Annabelle41415 Member Posts: 6,742 Member
    John23 said:

    Kim -
    Kim -

    Re:
    "I've been thin all my life and always ate mushrooms, onions
    salads, tomatoes everyday and still got cancer. "


    We should keep in mind, that all store-bought veggies and fruits,
    and of course all meats... are treated at the farm and during
    processing for sale. Eating all that was once said to be good
    for us, may very well now, be killing us.

    Pesticides remain in the ground, and each crop multiplies the
    amount that remains. Mixtures of pesticides for each different
    crop, along with chemicals to enhance growing, all add to the
    unknown variable of toxins; how can anyone know what the
    interactions will result in, when no records of chemicals used
    have been recorded.

    And now nearly all countries are irradiating the food products,
    with many of the countries having no legal restriction to hold
    to specific limits of radiation used. That also adds to the
    carcinogenic effect of our food products.

    It may not be "just one peach", but the cumulative effect of all
    the processing of everything we eat, veggies, fruits, meat, fish....

    But.... there are depictions of humans with tumors, on cave walls....

    Stay well, Kim!
    (John)

    To others (you know who you are):

    It bothers me that there are some here that fear not doing chemo
    so much, that they denounce anything and anyone, that suggests
    that there is something better and safer than chemo and radiation.

    They seem to feel that they must scream from the rooftops,
    that anyone trying anything other than chemo and radiation
    is placing their life in extreme peril !

    And as a user of other than chemo/radiation, I find myself
    looking for that door that the others like me have walked
    out through...

    The others got tired of fighting the industry's brain washed,
    and gave up.

    I sincerely hate to "give up". I hate watching people die; of reading
    the sad news, month after month after month...

    I hate the thought of not telling about another way that works,
    especially when the so-called "proven way" is failing them,
    and they have no place but hospice to go.

    I'm only human, just as the others like me are. I'm tired of arguing
    against the industry, and against all those that believe so
    much in the industry's answer to cancer.

    It's almost six years for me... my "luck" isn't going to last forever...

    Golly gee. I sure wish I did chemo instead of those stupid herbs.

    </sarcasm>

    Happy, cheerful, and healthy thoughts to all!

    John
    John
    You are right about the pesticides. Just don't think they thought much about using those as being so bad.

    Be well yourself too :) Kim
  • Buckwirth
    Buckwirth Member Posts: 1,258 Member
    John23 said:

    Humph

    So when I post information regarding the "fact" that nothing has
    improved with cancer therapy for the past 40 years, and I
    reference the data from a "blog"..... That's considered inferior
    data. But when it's posted in favor of the cancer industry,
    and the references come from a "blog", that's real data.

    Life's funny, ain't it?

    My best to youse all.

    John

    My criticism
    Was that the author of your "blog" was selling services that depended on you believing in his point of view. A conflict of interest you have been quick to raise yourself on more than one occasion.

    In all good humor, humph right back at you.
  • Buckwirth
    Buckwirth Member Posts: 1,258 Member
    Buckwirth said:

    My criticism
    Was that the author of your "blog" was selling services that depended on you believing in his point of view. A conflict of interest you have been quick to raise yourself on more than one occasion.

    In all good humor, humph right back at you.

    To make this clear
    Since you are accusing me of being duplicitous and inconsistent, and since most will not remember the previous kerfuffle you referred to, here is a little background on your "blogger"

    Ralph Moss - cancerdecisions.com
    Ralph Moss was the science writer who took it upon himself to make public preliminary mouse studies of Laetrile at MSKCC. At this time he has makes a living selling the Moss Report (his "blog") for about $270 per article. He does post some things at no charge, but the appearance that those are teaser articles to get you to pay for one of his reports is hard to get past. Here is a sample:
    Sample Colon Cancer Report
    He also sells access to his current, smaller articles at a rate of $9.95 to $19.95:
    Moss Report - Current Topics

    Now, the blogger that I linked to does have ads on his site. At my last visit they included an ad for a Las Vegas hotel and a CD by Michael Buble. Since his writings do not seem to cover recommendations for Vegas hotels, or the appropriate lounge music to use when you are in a romantic mood, I find nothing that can be viewed as a conflict of interest. His blog also carries the following disclaimer:

    "Disclaimer

    This is a personal web log, reflecting the sometimes prickly opinions of its author. Statements on this blog do not represent the opinions of anyone other than the author... 

    ...In addition, Orac has been funded over the last decade by institutional funds, theDepartment of Defense, the National Cancer Institute, and various cancer charities. He currently receives no funding from pharmaceutical companies. Indeed, so bereft of pharmaceutical funding is poor, poor Orac that before his talks, when he is required to make his disclosures of conflicts of interest, he often jokes that no pharmaceutical company is interested enough in his research to want to give him any money." 

    Moss, on the other hand, carries no such disclaimer.

    I like you, and in the past your advice has been helpful to me as I am sure it has been to others. Where you and I get into trouble are in cases like this where you are a bit loose with the facts, and sometimes (again in this case) where your statements could be interpreted as personal attacks. Most of the time I write the attacks off to your sharp sense of humor (something we share to a certain degree), though at others it has happened to cut a bit too deeply.

    All of that said, I hope you are doing well,

    Blake
  • Buckwirth
    Buckwirth Member Posts: 1,258 Member
    John23 said:

    Kim -
    Kim -

    Re:
    "I've been thin all my life and always ate mushrooms, onions
    salads, tomatoes everyday and still got cancer. "


    We should keep in mind, that all store-bought veggies and fruits,
    and of course all meats... are treated at the farm and during
    processing for sale. Eating all that was once said to be good
    for us, may very well now, be killing us.

    Pesticides remain in the ground, and each crop multiplies the
    amount that remains. Mixtures of pesticides for each different
    crop, along with chemicals to enhance growing, all add to the
    unknown variable of toxins; how can anyone know what the
    interactions will result in, when no records of chemicals used
    have been recorded.

    And now nearly all countries are irradiating the food products,
    with many of the countries having no legal restriction to hold
    to specific limits of radiation used. That also adds to the
    carcinogenic effect of our food products.

    It may not be "just one peach", but the cumulative effect of all
    the processing of everything we eat, veggies, fruits, meat, fish....

    But.... there are depictions of humans with tumors, on cave walls....

    Stay well, Kim!
    (John)

    To others (you know who you are):

    It bothers me that there are some here that fear not doing chemo
    so much, that they denounce anything and anyone, that suggests
    that there is something better and safer than chemo and radiation.

    They seem to feel that they must scream from the rooftops,
    that anyone trying anything other than chemo and radiation
    is placing their life in extreme peril !

    And as a user of other than chemo/radiation, I find myself
    looking for that door that the others like me have walked
    out through...

    The others got tired of fighting the industry's brain washed,
    and gave up.

    I sincerely hate to "give up". I hate watching people die; of reading
    the sad news, month after month after month...

    I hate the thought of not telling about another way that works,
    especially when the so-called "proven way" is failing them,
    and they have no place but hospice to go.

    I'm only human, just as the others like me are. I'm tired of arguing
    against the industry, and against all those that believe so
    much in the industry's answer to cancer.

    It's almost six years for me... my "luck" isn't going to last forever...

    Golly gee. I sure wish I did chemo instead of those stupid herbs.

    </sarcasm>

    Happy, cheerful, and healthy thoughts to all!

    John
    Again to be clear
    Pete has done chemo, and his treatment does not recommend any further therapies administered by an oncologist. His posts are not meant to advise that someone use another treatment modality, just lifestyle choices for one who is trying to prevent remission.

    When we correct Pete, or call into question one of his sources, we are not

    "...denounce(ing) anything and anyone, that suggests

    that there is something better and safer than chemo and radiation." 

    , nor are we challenging him based on "fear". I do wish you would stop using that word, it is demeaning to those you disagree with, and you tend to use it to imply that anyone who does not follow your path is doing so out of an emotional response rather than a reasoned one, and it can be interpreted as a personal attack.
  • laurettas
    laurettas Member Posts: 372
    John23 said:

    Kim -
    Kim -

    Re:
    "I've been thin all my life and always ate mushrooms, onions
    salads, tomatoes everyday and still got cancer. "


    We should keep in mind, that all store-bought veggies and fruits,
    and of course all meats... are treated at the farm and during
    processing for sale. Eating all that was once said to be good
    for us, may very well now, be killing us.

    Pesticides remain in the ground, and each crop multiplies the
    amount that remains. Mixtures of pesticides for each different
    crop, along with chemicals to enhance growing, all add to the
    unknown variable of toxins; how can anyone know what the
    interactions will result in, when no records of chemicals used
    have been recorded.

    And now nearly all countries are irradiating the food products,
    with many of the countries having no legal restriction to hold
    to specific limits of radiation used. That also adds to the
    carcinogenic effect of our food products.

    It may not be "just one peach", but the cumulative effect of all
    the processing of everything we eat, veggies, fruits, meat, fish....

    But.... there are depictions of humans with tumors, on cave walls....

    Stay well, Kim!
    (John)

    To others (you know who you are):

    It bothers me that there are some here that fear not doing chemo
    so much, that they denounce anything and anyone, that suggests
    that there is something better and safer than chemo and radiation.

    They seem to feel that they must scream from the rooftops,
    that anyone trying anything other than chemo and radiation
    is placing their life in extreme peril !

    And as a user of other than chemo/radiation, I find myself
    looking for that door that the others like me have walked
    out through...

    The others got tired of fighting the industry's brain washed,
    and gave up.

    I sincerely hate to "give up". I hate watching people die; of reading
    the sad news, month after month after month...

    I hate the thought of not telling about another way that works,
    especially when the so-called "proven way" is failing them,
    and they have no place but hospice to go.

    I'm only human, just as the others like me are. I'm tired of arguing
    against the industry, and against all those that believe so
    much in the industry's answer to cancer.

    It's almost six years for me... my "luck" isn't going to last forever...

    Golly gee. I sure wish I did chemo instead of those stupid herbs.

    </sarcasm>

    Happy, cheerful, and healthy thoughts to all!

    John
    John
    Did I see a gauntlet flying through the air?! Thought I saw one and decided to take up the challenge. I am going to explain my position and I have to warn you, it is going to be a long post. You might want to take a nap and then fill up on something high caffeine because I have a lot to say.

    First, I want it to be known that I HATE chemo--and I mean hate. Chemotherapy took all but one of my children from me and my life's dream was to have a large family. I wanted children from the time I was a small child and chemo robbed me of that. Not to mention the difficulties that our marriage went through because of the infertility--I hate chemo for that as well.

    Jake had cancer, Hodgkin's disease, 34 years ago when I was pregnant with our only child. He was 24 and I was 22. They staged him at IV because he had some spots in his lungs that they were not sure about. They gave him massive amounts of chemo--nitrogen mustard, adriamycin, vincristine and a few others--because he was so young and healthy, and they really wanted to save him. I watched him puke his guts out, first food, then blood, then bile because they had nothing to counteract the nausea. I saw his veins being destroyed by the chemo because they didn't use ports in those days wondering if his heart and liver and other organs were being destroyed at the same time. Our GP gave him his drugs because we had no oncologist in the area at that time. Jake worked almost full time through ten months of this hell and by the time it was over he could barely do anything he was so weak. We didn't live near family and had no close friends at the time. We were each other's best friends. I shouldered this by myself while pregnant except for a month after our daughter was born when our mothers came up to help. Again I was 22.

    Obviously he was cured of the cancer. Am I grateful to the chemo for that? No, because the chemo had nothing to do with it. Many won't believe me about this but I don't care. I was there. I saw it happen and heard the amazement of the doctors. Jake was still in the hospital while they were trying to figure out what kind of treatment to give him. One evening after I left to go back to my aunt's house, he called me in shock. He had had a phenomenal occurrence while lying in his hospital bed. He was having deep anxiety about all that was taking place, so frightened of all that we were learning. While lying there, he saw a cloud come over his bed, a hand come out of the cloud and touch his shoulder. He was immediately calm and at peace and when he called I knew that SOMETHING had happened because of the tone of his voice. Now you must understand, we were not religious freaks--I had barely come to accept that a being as God may possibly exist by that time and Jake was not a pious person by any means even though he had gone to a Catholic school. How do we know it was God? Well, the one thing that Jake got besides the peace was a huge desire to read the Bible--he would read it at work when no one was looking and could not get enough of it. Scripture became his passion--a secret one because he certainly didn't want anyone to think that he was a religious nut!

    Now fast forward two months to his first checkup after two months of chemo. They did an X-ray and were shocked. His fist sized tumors were gone--no where to be seen. The doctors couldn't believe it. They said that chemo doesn't work that way. That tumors DO NOT go away that quickly. One of them even threw out the term miracle. Did we understand what had happened? No, we were too stupid to equate the disappearance of his tumors with his vision in the hospital. We didn't realize for years that his cancer was cured by God. So, eight more months of hell were endured. We made a pact that if we had to decide about whether or not to take chemo again we would make sure that the statistics were on our side or we would not go through that horror ever again.

    Did it affect us and how we thought? Most definitely. One always wonders why a person gets cancer and we were no exceptions. We came up with two possibilities. First, Jake's mom was an X-ray technician in the early 1950's. She continued her job while she was pregnant, exposing Jake to radiation all the time she was pregnant because no shields or anything were used and she stood in the room while the X-rays were done. Second, we bought a new trailer house to live in a year an a half before Jake got cancer. The formaldehyde in it was so strong that our eyes would water every time our furnace came on--which was a lot in Montana winters. We would have the same problem every time we came back to our house after being away for a few hours. It was horrible. Those two possibilities did not endear me to the medical profession or to the use of unsafe chemicals.

    We determined that we were going to live as cancer-free as we possibly could and we delved into it wholeheartedly. We grew our own food--meat, vegetables, milk, eggs, we did it all except for fruit. Never got too far with that. We gardened organically, using the manure from our cows that ate the hay that we grew on our farm. The only non-organic things we did were to put a small amount of commercial fertilizer on our field and buy grain for our milk cow that was not organic. I even bought organic wheat and ground the flour and made our bread.

    I grew up with the knowledge of organic farming because of my mother. Her father had mental problems when she was young and he determined that it was the chemicals (DDT, etc) that he was spraying on farmers' crops that were causing his problems(don't know whether that was true or not). This was in the 1930's so my family's commitment to healthy food goes back a long way.

    A few years after Jake's cancer we built a house. We used knotty pine throughout the entire house. There were almost no sheets of plywood to be found in it. Jake and my dad cut the trees from my parents' property, sawed the lumber on my dad's mill and we built it with our own hands. A cancer free home.

    We lived in that house for over 25 years but sold it in order to move closer to our daughter and her family. We were in heaven because we were able to buy a larger property in the heart of grain-growing country so I could foresee the possibility of fulfilling my dream of growing pretty much all of our food, and our animals', on our farm. The only negative was that we bought a modular home to put on the property so had to deal with the chemicals in the home again. Not nearly as severe as our trailer had been but we can still smell them when we shut up the house and leave for a few days.

    A couple of years ago, the granddaughter of some friends of ours was diagnosed with neuroblastoma. I read about it on the internet. The statistics were horrible--something like a 10% chance of living over five years with her stage IV diagnosis. I remembered my commitment to making decisions on the statistics. We watched her go through horrible treatments but the cancer kept coming back and coming back. It was horrible. She just died a couple of weeks ago. She was six years old.

    Oh, yes, one of Jake's cousins also had a daughter with neuroblastoma about 25 years ago. They had even less success with it then than today. They chose no treatment. She died in two months.

    Now we are up to Jake's new diagnosis of cancer. I again remembered our commitment to statistics. I read the statistics and passed them on to Jake--his were worse than normal stage IV colon cancer because of his signet ring cell diagnosis. I was devastated but remembered our commitment. However, I did have the additional knowledge of the chemo that my dad went through for colon cancer and it was nothing like Jake's had been so I knew that not all chemo was as horrific as that which Jake and the little girl endured.

    I knew that this was not my decision to make. I gave my thoughts on it but the decision was Jake's. He decided to take the chemo. I began a vast search on the internet for all things concerning cancer, chemotherapy, alternatives, etc. And of course you get a lot of people's input as well. People sending us bottles of pills, calling with information about this alternative treatment, that non-mainstream doctor, etc. etc. We would get excited and then I would research. Never could find the one thing that seemed to have evidence to back up the claims. I wanted to desperately because I HATE chemo. But I haven't found it. The best I have found is the people on these sites who have taken chemo and out-lived the statistics. I asked one person who juices and does all of that if she could share with me twelve people that she knows about with active cancer who used her methods and had their cancer cease growing or disappear. Haven't gotten those names from her yet.

    So, John, I am going to make the same request of you. Can you tell me of twelve people who have had active cancer and used only TCM to make their cancer go away? I read the sites you gave links to previously but I did not see stories of people with active cancer who had it cured by TCM. Most of the sites stated that TCM was not to be used alone but in conjunction with conventional treatment to temper the side effects. In China they use conventional treatments as well--have seen studies from there in my research. You see, I HATE chemo, I know what it can do to individuals and families and I want desperately to find something else that works better, but I can't go on one or two examples. I have read that many accounts of people who did nothing and their cancer went away. So, John, if you have that information, please share it with us. We would love an alternative to this chemo that we hate.
  • pete43lost_at_sea
    pete43lost_at_sea Member Posts: 3,900 Member
    laurettas said:

    John
    Did I see a gauntlet flying through the air?! Thought I saw one and decided to take up the challenge. I am going to explain my position and I have to warn you, it is going to be a long post. You might want to take a nap and then fill up on something high caffeine because I have a lot to say.

    First, I want it to be known that I HATE chemo--and I mean hate. Chemotherapy took all but one of my children from me and my life's dream was to have a large family. I wanted children from the time I was a small child and chemo robbed me of that. Not to mention the difficulties that our marriage went through because of the infertility--I hate chemo for that as well.

    Jake had cancer, Hodgkin's disease, 34 years ago when I was pregnant with our only child. He was 24 and I was 22. They staged him at IV because he had some spots in his lungs that they were not sure about. They gave him massive amounts of chemo--nitrogen mustard, adriamycin, vincristine and a few others--because he was so young and healthy, and they really wanted to save him. I watched him puke his guts out, first food, then blood, then bile because they had nothing to counteract the nausea. I saw his veins being destroyed by the chemo because they didn't use ports in those days wondering if his heart and liver and other organs were being destroyed at the same time. Our GP gave him his drugs because we had no oncologist in the area at that time. Jake worked almost full time through ten months of this hell and by the time it was over he could barely do anything he was so weak. We didn't live near family and had no close friends at the time. We were each other's best friends. I shouldered this by myself while pregnant except for a month after our daughter was born when our mothers came up to help. Again I was 22.

    Obviously he was cured of the cancer. Am I grateful to the chemo for that? No, because the chemo had nothing to do with it. Many won't believe me about this but I don't care. I was there. I saw it happen and heard the amazement of the doctors. Jake was still in the hospital while they were trying to figure out what kind of treatment to give him. One evening after I left to go back to my aunt's house, he called me in shock. He had had a phenomenal occurrence while lying in his hospital bed. He was having deep anxiety about all that was taking place, so frightened of all that we were learning. While lying there, he saw a cloud come over his bed, a hand come out of the cloud and touch his shoulder. He was immediately calm and at peace and when he called I knew that SOMETHING had happened because of the tone of his voice. Now you must understand, we were not religious freaks--I had barely come to accept that a being as God may possibly exist by that time and Jake was not a pious person by any means even though he had gone to a Catholic school. How do we know it was God? Well, the one thing that Jake got besides the peace was a huge desire to read the Bible--he would read it at work when no one was looking and could not get enough of it. Scripture became his passion--a secret one because he certainly didn't want anyone to think that he was a religious nut!

    Now fast forward two months to his first checkup after two months of chemo. They did an X-ray and were shocked. His fist sized tumors were gone--no where to be seen. The doctors couldn't believe it. They said that chemo doesn't work that way. That tumors DO NOT go away that quickly. One of them even threw out the term miracle. Did we understand what had happened? No, we were too stupid to equate the disappearance of his tumors with his vision in the hospital. We didn't realize for years that his cancer was cured by God. So, eight more months of hell were endured. We made a pact that if we had to decide about whether or not to take chemo again we would make sure that the statistics were on our side or we would not go through that horror ever again.

    Did it affect us and how we thought? Most definitely. One always wonders why a person gets cancer and we were no exceptions. We came up with two possibilities. First, Jake's mom was an X-ray technician in the early 1950's. She continued her job while she was pregnant, exposing Jake to radiation all the time she was pregnant because no shields or anything were used and she stood in the room while the X-rays were done. Second, we bought a new trailer house to live in a year an a half before Jake got cancer. The formaldehyde in it was so strong that our eyes would water every time our furnace came on--which was a lot in Montana winters. We would have the same problem every time we came back to our house after being away for a few hours. It was horrible. Those two possibilities did not endear me to the medical profession or to the use of unsafe chemicals.

    We determined that we were going to live as cancer-free as we possibly could and we delved into it wholeheartedly. We grew our own food--meat, vegetables, milk, eggs, we did it all except for fruit. Never got too far with that. We gardened organically, using the manure from our cows that ate the hay that we grew on our farm. The only non-organic things we did were to put a small amount of commercial fertilizer on our field and buy grain for our milk cow that was not organic. I even bought organic wheat and ground the flour and made our bread.

    I grew up with the knowledge of organic farming because of my mother. Her father had mental problems when she was young and he determined that it was the chemicals (DDT, etc) that he was spraying on farmers' crops that were causing his problems(don't know whether that was true or not). This was in the 1930's so my family's commitment to healthy food goes back a long way.

    A few years after Jake's cancer we built a house. We used knotty pine throughout the entire house. There were almost no sheets of plywood to be found in it. Jake and my dad cut the trees from my parents' property, sawed the lumber on my dad's mill and we built it with our own hands. A cancer free home.

    We lived in that house for over 25 years but sold it in order to move closer to our daughter and her family. We were in heaven because we were able to buy a larger property in the heart of grain-growing country so I could foresee the possibility of fulfilling my dream of growing pretty much all of our food, and our animals', on our farm. The only negative was that we bought a modular home to put on the property so had to deal with the chemicals in the home again. Not nearly as severe as our trailer had been but we can still smell them when we shut up the house and leave for a few days.

    A couple of years ago, the granddaughter of some friends of ours was diagnosed with neuroblastoma. I read about it on the internet. The statistics were horrible--something like a 10% chance of living over five years with her stage IV diagnosis. I remembered my commitment to making decisions on the statistics. We watched her go through horrible treatments but the cancer kept coming back and coming back. It was horrible. She just died a couple of weeks ago. She was six years old.

    Oh, yes, one of Jake's cousins also had a daughter with neuroblastoma about 25 years ago. They had even less success with it then than today. They chose no treatment. She died in two months.

    Now we are up to Jake's new diagnosis of cancer. I again remembered our commitment to statistics. I read the statistics and passed them on to Jake--his were worse than normal stage IV colon cancer because of his signet ring cell diagnosis. I was devastated but remembered our commitment. However, I did have the additional knowledge of the chemo that my dad went through for colon cancer and it was nothing like Jake's had been so I knew that not all chemo was as horrific as that which Jake and the little girl endured.

    I knew that this was not my decision to make. I gave my thoughts on it but the decision was Jake's. He decided to take the chemo. I began a vast search on the internet for all things concerning cancer, chemotherapy, alternatives, etc. And of course you get a lot of people's input as well. People sending us bottles of pills, calling with information about this alternative treatment, that non-mainstream doctor, etc. etc. We would get excited and then I would research. Never could find the one thing that seemed to have evidence to back up the claims. I wanted to desperately because I HATE chemo. But I haven't found it. The best I have found is the people on these sites who have taken chemo and out-lived the statistics. I asked one person who juices and does all of that if she could share with me twelve people that she knows about with active cancer who used her methods and had their cancer cease growing or disappear. Haven't gotten those names from her yet.

    So, John, I am going to make the same request of you. Can you tell me of twelve people who have had active cancer and used only TCM to make their cancer go away? I read the sites you gave links to previously but I did not see stories of people with active cancer who had it cured by TCM. Most of the sites stated that TCM was not to be used alone but in conjunction with conventional treatment to temper the side effects. In China they use conventional treatments as well--have seen studies from there in my research. You see, I HATE chemo, I know what it can do to individuals and families and I want desperately to find something else that works better, but I can't go on one or two examples. I have read that many accounts of people who did nothing and their cancer went away. So, John, if you have that information, please share it with us. We would love an alternative to this chemo that we hate.

    thanks laurettas
    i'll let john reply, but just wanted to thankyou for sharing your story, its amazing.
    John has shared his story, and his experiences mainly with tcm. As one of the few here who takes tcm everyday as prescribed by my chinese oncologist i wanted to add.

    i have met people who have far outlived their western doctors useby dates. so many personal stories, i met them in the waiting rooms, i did not ask for their name and addresses. they tried chemo and still had challenges, for them tcm worked and still works.

    we all have treatment choices ? everyday , everynight i am fighting my cancer, trying to have a healthy life.

    asking for 12 people for juicing or tcm is the number you require. for me the number could be zero, 1, or 100. you are free to ask for the proof i guess you are seeking, if you don't get the answer you need. then i guess you make your decision. it does not diminish what other people believe or have faith in.

    I have faith in juicing and tcm for myself and thats good enough for me.

    Its strange the difference, I love my folfox, its given me a shot at life, the TCM practioneers i visited befoe surgery and radiation said use the western treatments and tcm at the same time and thats what i did. I followed my gut feel, that all any of us can do with the choices before us.

    hugs,
    pete
  • pete43lost_at_sea
    pete43lost_at_sea Member Posts: 3,900 Member
    Buckwirth said:
    thanks blake, but just white noise
    the blog is about The spontaneous regression of breast cancer?
    it takes a shot at joel.
    but his book and the studies of anti angiogenic foods was the point of this post.

    just what specific foods can help our bodies heal and fight cancer naturally.
    tumeric, tomatoes, blueberries, flakseed.

    everything that comes through my lips to my digestive system is anticancer.

    i hugged another mans wife today when noone else did, she was crying, she hugged me back.

    he was sitting in his wheel chair, he gave me the biggest smile and turned his thumb up. a great positive gesture. he cannot talk anymore, has weeks to live. i don't even know what his cancer is,but he was at the meditation support group this morning. they have changed my life for ever.

    is being thin, no fat a worthwhile goal for all of us crc's ?
    i was told yes by naturopaths, nothing by onc.

    if i swap the fast food fries and shake and have broccoli, mangoes, mung beans, pawpaw, flak seed, tomatoes, beetroot, lettuce, red onion, broccoli sprouts, mushroom.

    i believe my lunch above helps me get thinner, helps my body have the nutrients it needs to be strong for my treatment.

    I view my exercise and my diet and meditation as an extension of my treatment.

    are you aware of all the lifestyle intervention trials running around the world as we speak on crc, well i am. i am just doing it myself.

    by all means add to the conversation in a constructive way, keep it focused on the subject at hand, which is simply anti angiogenic foods, what about the angiogenic foundation ?

    some say we are what we eat, i think its to limited, we are also what we say, write, breathe and think.

    science based medicine can only take us so far, it took science based medicine 100 to beleive in washing hands, decent hygenie.

    why not cherry pick from pubmed every study that got potential benefits for us crc's.

    hugs,
    Pete
  • pete43lost_at_sea
    pete43lost_at_sea Member Posts: 3,900 Member

    Ummmmm
    I've been thin all my life and always ate mushrooms, onions salads, tomatoes everyday and still got cancer. Sometimes I've got a really hard time believing in what people claim but if it works for you or them then I say go for it.

    Kim

    sorry skinny you got crc
    now i am almost skinny i figured i could say that.
    i just read and share, being fat is just wrong for me.

    now i look good, i got the new small swimmers, i can walk around the pool and get my vitamin d.

    i am not expecting any guarantees with my diet, but am optimistic from my studies.
    the books focused on specific anticancer foods, back by research.

    did you eat raw broccoli, carrots, brussel sprouts.

    raw brussel sprouts are my new apples. I am going for it. My bm's are getting better with the green sludge i drink daily now. just google vital green for details.

    http://www.vitalgreens.com/
    these guys are local for me, i know lef does this as well in the us.

    and the bm's also benefit from yoga and my core strength training.

    hugs,
    Pete
  • Buckwirth
    Buckwirth Member Posts: 1,258 Member

    thanks blake, but just white noise
    the blog is about The spontaneous regression of breast cancer?
    it takes a shot at joel.
    but his book and the studies of anti angiogenic foods was the point of this post.

    just what specific foods can help our bodies heal and fight cancer naturally.
    tumeric, tomatoes, blueberries, flakseed.

    everything that comes through my lips to my digestive system is anticancer.

    i hugged another mans wife today when noone else did, she was crying, she hugged me back.

    he was sitting in his wheel chair, he gave me the biggest smile and turned his thumb up. a great positive gesture. he cannot talk anymore, has weeks to live. i don't even know what his cancer is,but he was at the meditation support group this morning. they have changed my life for ever.

    is being thin, no fat a worthwhile goal for all of us crc's ?
    i was told yes by naturopaths, nothing by onc.

    if i swap the fast food fries and shake and have broccoli, mangoes, mung beans, pawpaw, flak seed, tomatoes, beetroot, lettuce, red onion, broccoli sprouts, mushroom.

    i believe my lunch above helps me get thinner, helps my body have the nutrients it needs to be strong for my treatment.

    I view my exercise and my diet and meditation as an extension of my treatment.

    are you aware of all the lifestyle intervention trials running around the world as we speak on crc, well i am. i am just doing it myself.

    by all means add to the conversation in a constructive way, keep it focused on the subject at hand, which is simply anti angiogenic foods, what about the angiogenic foundation ?

    some say we are what we eat, i think its to limited, we are also what we say, write, breathe and think.

    science based medicine can only take us so far, it took science based medicine 100 to beleive in washing hands, decent hygenie.

    why not cherry pick from pubmed every study that got potential benefits for us crc's.

    hugs,
    Pete

    A source is a source
    and its quality matters (not all sources are equal, kind of like opinions). If the source has a history of misrepresenting information, or of just being unreliable, it should not be trusted, even if it happens to be good info (kind of like the boy who cried wolf). This is not meant as an insult Pete, just an observation:

    You tend to expound on whatever was the last thing you heard. At some point, you hear something new and move on.

    As to PubMed, it is a great resource, but it does not filter for quality of study, or discriminate as to the journal in which it was published. I have come to prefer reviews, and phase 3 human trials before making a judgement as to whether something is good or bad. As a for instance, Lauretta's posted the EPIC study, which showed a higher rate of CRC in those following a vegetarian diet (as well as a lower overall cancer rate on the same diet). My response noted I found the data interesting, but there may be problems with the way the study was structured, or in how it drew its conclusions. I consider myself fairly intelligent, but will wait for others who are more qualified than I to review that study before I change my diet (of course, that horse has left the barn for me anyway, nothing I do is going to change my CRC risk, or my risk of recurrence).

    Lastly, the title of your thread implies the main issue is fat. We all agree that a healthy weight is probably the single best thing that can be done to prevent cancer. Whether you get there with a vegan diet, exercising, or by following Atkins is entirely up to you.
  • Buckwirth
    Buckwirth Member Posts: 1,258 Member

    thanks laurettas
    i'll let john reply, but just wanted to thankyou for sharing your story, its amazing.
    John has shared his story, and his experiences mainly with tcm. As one of the few here who takes tcm everyday as prescribed by my chinese oncologist i wanted to add.

    i have met people who have far outlived their western doctors useby dates. so many personal stories, i met them in the waiting rooms, i did not ask for their name and addresses. they tried chemo and still had challenges, for them tcm worked and still works.

    we all have treatment choices ? everyday , everynight i am fighting my cancer, trying to have a healthy life.

    asking for 12 people for juicing or tcm is the number you require. for me the number could be zero, 1, or 100. you are free to ask for the proof i guess you are seeking, if you don't get the answer you need. then i guess you make your decision. it does not diminish what other people believe or have faith in.

    I have faith in juicing and tcm for myself and thats good enough for me.

    Its strange the difference, I love my folfox, its given me a shot at life, the TCM practioneers i visited befoe surgery and radiation said use the western treatments and tcm at the same time and thats what i did. I followed my gut feel, that all any of us can do with the choices before us.

    hugs,
    pete

    "i have met people who have far outlived their western doctors useby dates..." 

    Seems to me everyone here who got a "use by" date has outlived it. Those stories are a dime a dozen, and could be as related to the fact they all wore comfortable shoes....
  • laurettas
    laurettas Member Posts: 372

    thanks laurettas
    i'll let john reply, but just wanted to thankyou for sharing your story, its amazing.
    John has shared his story, and his experiences mainly with tcm. As one of the few here who takes tcm everyday as prescribed by my chinese oncologist i wanted to add.

    i have met people who have far outlived their western doctors useby dates. so many personal stories, i met them in the waiting rooms, i did not ask for their name and addresses. they tried chemo and still had challenges, for them tcm worked and still works.

    we all have treatment choices ? everyday , everynight i am fighting my cancer, trying to have a healthy life.

    asking for 12 people for juicing or tcm is the number you require. for me the number could be zero, 1, or 100. you are free to ask for the proof i guess you are seeking, if you don't get the answer you need. then i guess you make your decision. it does not diminish what other people believe or have faith in.

    I have faith in juicing and tcm for myself and thats good enough for me.

    Its strange the difference, I love my folfox, its given me a shot at life, the TCM practioneers i visited befoe surgery and radiation said use the western treatments and tcm at the same time and thats what i did. I followed my gut feel, that all any of us can do with the choices before us.

    hugs,
    pete

    You're welcome, Pete
    For me, I cannot recommend something to my husband that hasn't had some track record of success. Everyone that I know personally that has tried an alternative method has died. Maybe they didn't do it right or waited too long or whatever, I don't know but they died. I have several family members and friends who have used conventional Western medicine and survived cancer. Not all but several. I probably have 12 members of my own family who have survived cancer so it wouldn't seem that twelve would be a large number to ask as a recommendation for any particular alternative treatment. If I am going on "faith" with no evidence of benefit, I will do nothing! It is much easier and I have heard of people whose cancer just spontaneously disappeared. I don't understand why that is such a controversial thing to ask for concrete evidence of success. To me it is common sense and scientific!
  • tanstaafl
    tanstaafl Member Posts: 1,313 Member
    laurettas said:

    You're welcome, Pete
    For me, I cannot recommend something to my husband that hasn't had some track record of success. Everyone that I know personally that has tried an alternative method has died. Maybe they didn't do it right or waited too long or whatever, I don't know but they died. I have several family members and friends who have used conventional Western medicine and survived cancer. Not all but several. I probably have 12 members of my own family who have survived cancer so it wouldn't seem that twelve would be a large number to ask as a recommendation for any particular alternative treatment. If I am going on "faith" with no evidence of benefit, I will do nothing! It is much easier and I have heard of people whose cancer just spontaneously disappeared. I don't understand why that is such a controversial thing to ask for concrete evidence of success. To me it is common sense and scientific!

    risk and uncertainty
    It's not such a controversial thing to ask for concrete evidence of success, just the threshold can be too expectant, especially for free, - too intrusive, too expensive, too distant in time, as well as many proposed answers being nonexistent, or nonsense.

    Our technical resources, capabilities, experience, and personalities shape how close we're willing to play it to the bone. Refusal to take a risk can sometimes be more risky.
  • tanstaafl
    tanstaafl Member Posts: 1,313 Member
    "...got cancer anyway"
    I don't worry so much about chemical residues on vegetables, not thrilled, try to keep them down, but it's the other much larger chemistry mistakes that bother me.

    mushrooms, onions salads, tomatoes everyday...got cancer anyway"
    Our diets themselves were and are so conflicted with major chemical mistakes, we are naifs lucky to dodge more than 2-3 bullets. If size of manufactured junk sections of the grocery stores translates to national diet, we're still in deep diet decline. Ditto weight gain and diabetes.

    We've been raised on misinformation, yielding diets that were loaded with oxidized polyunsaturated fats, transfats, sugars, starches, thermally altered carbs and proteins, antibiotics, hormone disruptors (container), rogue elements (e.g. mercury, cadmium, lead, aluminum, fluorine), chemicals in water (phenols, solvents, chloro-) and chronic meds while grossly depleted on essential nutrients like long chain omega-3s, vitamin D3, magnesium, B complex, probably vitamin K and other near vitamin-like substances. Our biology is impressive that we're not more sick, or extinct. We've been pushing out some (bio)chemical boundaries for a long time.

    We are only on the early edge of scientifically complete nutrition and toxicology, with nutrigenomics and metabolomics. The most important thing is to learn the best answers that we can, teach our kids, and help others.